seanpb wrote:
my opinion, for what its worth (and, really, the only person who matters is myself), Gibbs is a better player than Selwood.
I'm not saying that through rose colored glasses, I'm not saying that with bias loyalty to a guy who plays for us... I just think that time will tell that Gibbs is a more talented footballer.
Is he as hard as Selwood? probably not, but Joel's body will feel the effects of his reckless attack on the footy one day. That's not saying Bryce is soft, not at all, just that when we really get up and running our boy will prove his worth.
Either way, the question isn't 'whose better?' in this thread, anyway. It's 'is Gibbs a star?'. Is he a star right at this moment? once again, probably not.
Will he be? Absolutely, not a doubt in my mind. We have one of those most brilliantly gifted footballers I've had the pleasure of seeing. His vision, range of passing, awareness (save a few little hiccups here and there), work in traffic, coolness and temperament all prove to me he is a star.
2010, and possibly September 2009, will be Bryce's big year.
I like your opinion.
Your opinion could be good friends with my opinion.
However...I look at Bryce right now...and I definitely(sp??) see a luminous glowing star....it is there.It's hard to miss really.
Bryce Gibbs =star and a star can rise to meet its full zenith.