Pros:

after todays performance I think the best things to come from this year are

JAMO is the revelation of the YEAR - New jersey and new number ordered.

GIBBS comming on in leaps and bounds is the feel good story of the year we knew would happen.

GRIGG has blossomed and I think suprised everyone and I couldnt be happier

WAITE I pefer as CHF but is almost unstoppable as CHB - a complete success as he is playing out of his skin even disposals have improved

FISH has been down on confidence but still presents well and runs all day
Someone should tell the guy JUST to do snap kicks - they are by far his most accurate kick this year.

There is something not right if 2 shots from the same spot one goes left and right goes right of the goals....

SIMMO - Complemented by TEX - nuff said

Bring on 2009

- Get to see a 10 goal belting fo the first time live
- Gibbs first half
- Judds 2nd half - stamped class
- Scooter good
- Murph was good today but like gibbs was well held at times

- Carrazzo was solid all day yes he did his run off back of packs for handball recieves but at least now his next disposal is to a carlton player moving forward and rarely missed a beat today - like last week GOOD WORK SON keep it up id say was BOG as he played well for 4 quarters.

- Saddo played OK thos saying he didnt do too much or anything should I dont know watch it again gave more then hartlet and edwards and even pushed forward and caused a few headaches - he played well.

Cons:

- I love Army and his dash only concern when he is running forward he tends to just jam the ball on his boot - granted its probably more effective then most but yeah needs a bit of work.

- Should have buried them at 15min mark of the 1st
- over finnessing the ball

Biggest CON for the entire match:

- Although we were wininng Carlton supporters behind me in the social club found every reason to bag our players constantly ....You wouldnt have thought we were winning all DAY....

*comments removed*

I can imagine you didn't enjoy it much but if you are going to post this sort of stuff in a public forum you are no better. A lot of people are very offended by this sort of blasphemy, me for one. Please bear that in mind before you write it.

I can imagine you didn't enjoy it much but if you are going to post this sort of stuff in a public forum you are no better. A lot of people are very offended by this sort of blasphemy, me for one. Please bear that in mind before you write it.

Pros:
1. We have very good flankers now (Grigg, Walker, Scotland, Simpson).
2. Defensive pressure has gone up a notch: Kreuzer, Walker, Armfield have added a lot.
3. We are getting something out of Wiggins every week, and he is not letting us down in any way
4. Carrazzo has obviously put the 'long kick' in the rack and has realised he is best off short passing. As a result, he has really turned his form around the last two weeks and is on fire IMO. Hard running, winning contests, not fumbling, making good decisions, stopping opposition mid/forwards. Using the ball well. He just cant create with kicking but given everything else he does, who cares?
5. Waite has sealed his All Australian selection

Cons:
1. Fisher's kicking is getting worse.
2. Cloke is too slow but they keep playing him (and will continue to do so)
3. our general field kicking is substandard and needs to improve

Con: why do we seem to have only one player who is referred to as a crumber/goalsneak?

As bondi says, there were some bread and butter crumber's goals which should have been grabbed by a crumber, but Eddie was out. So who do we have who can fill that role when Eddie's injured, or when he's tagged, or when he's being rotated somewhere else?

Walker filled Eddie's role yesterday with some minor variations.

At centre bounces Walks was standing exactly where Eddie would in the setup, 15 metres ahead of Fev

Con: why do we seem to have only one player who is referred to as a crumber/goalsneak?

As bondi says, there were some bread and butter crumber's goals which should have been grabbed by a crumber, but Eddie was out. So who do we have who can fill that role when Eddie's injured, or when he's tagged, or when he's being rotated somewhere else?

Pros:
1. We have very good flankers now (Grigg, Walker, Scotland, Simpson).
2. Defensive pressure has gone up a notch: Kreuzer, Walker, Armfield have added a lot.
3. We are getting something out of Wiggins every week, and he is not letting us down in any way
4. Carrazzo has obviously put the 'long kick' in the rack and has realised he is best off short passing. As a result, he has really turned his form around the last two weeks and is on fire IMO. Hard running, winning contests, not fumbling, making good decisions, stopping opposition mid/forwards. Using the ball well. He just cant create with kicking but given everything else he does, who cares?
5. Waite has sealed his All Australian selection

Cons:
1. Fisher's kicking is getting worse.
2. Cloke is too slow but they keep playing him (and will continue to do so)
3. our general field kicking is substandard and needs to improve

Pro: Everything thats been said already.

Con: Can't find a torrent of the game.