Sydney Blue wrote:
walkers a gun wrote:
4 YEARS IN THE SYSTEM... 4 FREAKIN YEARS and what has he done? Where is the improvement? I understand the kids had it hard regarding confidence with Pagen but CMON...
This is meant to be the new Carlton where we're moving forward and that should mean not playing people like Russel, Sadington, Ackland, Wiggins and Bentic.
Time to start playing guys like Armfield, Browne, Jackson, Austin, both the Irish boys, Anderson, Benjamin. We need to know now what these kids can do because this isnt the year for the Premiership, that will hopefuly come in 2-4 years and if w play em now then come 2010 they will be playing there 15th game (atleast) not their 1st or 2nd.
THE BEST WAY FOR THEM TO LEARN IS TO GIVE THEM A GO ON THE BIG STAGE!
find a stats site somewhere and have a look at Fevs first 4 years and Simpson only really started to blossum about half way through his fourth year - then take a look at Hadleys and Waites , Ohalpins - give him time he is getting better
Your not seriously comparing russel to Waite and Fev are you??? Fev showed signs of being a gun forward, Waite showed sign of a super athlete and Ohalpins have shown more improvement in their time at the club then Russel.
I am not the person who wants to delist guys for a few bad games, i say delist someone after 4 bad years and shows no signs of improvement and dont forget he was a top 10 pick.
Back to your hilarious comparisons, Simpson showed us he can run and tackel and in time he would be an asset.
let me aks you, what has Russel showed us in his 4 years???????? I really want your opinion on this.