tap in 79 wrote:
keogh wrote:
dannyboy wrote:
what on earth are you on about?
Ashcroft going okay?
All I am saying is you know nothing of current bloke apart from that he is from finance, that's it but because he isn't a she he must be [REDACTED]..stupid thinking really.
list and suspect the club may have come to the same conclusion last year. Of course we will never know.
every where
Isn’t Brisbane lucky to use the fathers-son rule to pick up THE best player in the draft by handing over rubbish picks in the 50s or whatever?
Ashcroft will be a legendary player. Not hard to pick him. Don’t need to be a recruiting genius.
This year’s draft will further the process with fathers-sons/academy picks meaning you will wait until the 20s at least to get a pick.
The AFL wants the loophole to persist. A fair competition would have made them pay market rates for Ashcroft etc.. but Naah.
Match committee.. bit confused by why they pick Pittonet. The winning ratio with him in drops significantly.. even in 2023. If you have a ruckman who can’t mark the ball… there’s not much point.
Justin Madden in his heyday could take 11 marks in a game. It would take 11 matches for Pittonet get this total. Young can mark the ball. Yes he has deficiencies, but not as much as Pittonet.
Once they picked him I knew the game was cactus.
Pitto is lame. He's not going to last 100 minutes of footy. Young too light for Xerri
He was picked to counter Xerri, who tore TDK a new one last time they met.
Yesterday we looked better with Pitto vs Xerri. see first quarter
Everytime TDK went in the ruck Xerri fed his mids. see 2nd quarter
That was highlighted ad nauseum during the Fox covergae by Gerard Healey, and his co hosts. Pitto nullified Xerris impact, and TDK didnt.
We were cactus because we were up against an inform team, growing by thje week, and their mids brutalised our mids.
When our mids fail, we fail. Nothing to do with Pitto or Young's selection non selection. Weak as piss.
.

Sorry, but I’m sticking by my opinion.
“Nullified” .. doesn’t really do much.
Rickmen today aren’t just bash and smash ruckmen.. the Collingwood ruckman kicked 2 or 3 goals in their match.
Pitto is one dimensional.
He might “nullify” but that doesn’t win you games.
If Young was playing.. charging down to the forward line, the North ruck would have to follow him (using up petrol tickets)
Young is lighter.. yes.. but in today’s football not really a hindrance (in my opinion)