club29 wrote:
keogh wrote:
The problem the club has is it’s about individual
Its not about the club
Individuals hide behind the logo
We are a powerful club therefore we are a good club
We are not
We had a sugar hit in 2023 with a game style that’s already outdated
Remember that the coaching position came down to two names
Voss and Kingsley
We went with the name not the best coach
Voss it seems incapable of changing the club’s game style and personal
It’s now 2 wins from the last 12 matches
That’s becoming a large sample size
The effort has been there the last 2 weeks but not the execution
Our recruitment team
Past and present haven’t been good enough
The club has this perception that because we have 5 or so gun players we are in the premiership window
Figure it out
We lose 7 of our last 9 games in 2024 have a coach that produces the worst coaching display I can remember ( Cincotta for Docherty that putting individuals before the club) then over the off season provide no new tactical support give away our first and second round picks off load good servants in Kennedy and Owies for Jaga Smith
Even if hadn’t done his knee he would not make much difference
Against individual over the club
We recruit AFL hacks in Haynes and Francis- Evans
In round one it was Blight
Round 2 it was Newcombe
In round 3 it was Davidson
All VFL and WAFL players pick in their early 20 s
Our recruiting is so @#$%&! narrow minded
Clearly what happened over summer shows where the club thought where we were at
In the premiership window .
This shows once again how the club places individuals over the club
We have the champs we will be alright
Injuries [REDACTED] us
Well that’s an excuse
GWS had just as many last yearn
It’s so @#$%&! dumb
And it hasn’t changed in 25 years
Our reserves our shit
Clearly not enough emphasis is placed on developing kids
In my time I have only seen one flag won by an individual
Martin in 2020
Every other year it’s won by the team with the best bottom 6 players
We focus too much on our better players and pay too much either money picks or both on players from other AFL clubs who we overrate time and time again
Honestly I can’t see us winning more than 11 games given the competition
I hope it all falls apart and the club finally takes action by saying we have a cultural problem
I would be happy for DeKoning to go
1.2 million would give us a pick 3
McKay I would trade
Besides easing salary cap pressure we would get a first rounder
Walsh for a first rounder
This needs to happen before Tassie come in
Get a coach who is good
Not a name
The alternative is to be at best mediocre
I love what Mitchell has done
We need to do something similar
I would like to think Wright might just get it and do something about it it
I dont think H would get us a first rounder. Bris would be the likely team. Maybe Wilmot and a 3rd.
Disagree - 200 cm key forwards who've won a Coleman don't grow on trees.
Just need to be hard negotiators and convince another club, especially a QLD/NSW club, that the change of scenery can help him overcome his soft side (it won't, but we need to sell that).
We should be aiming for a 1st rounder and a ready made player as a minimum.