GreatEx wrote:
Mosquito Fleet wrote:
just returned:
as I said last week - its all about out with the old in with the new
jamison
simpson
white
rowe
everitt
gibbs - he is trade bait material - if get a 1st round for him do it sos
thomas
kruzer
all need to be exited out asap - these guys wont get better and wont be with a premiership
still undecided about Broekhurst and Graham
happy with charlie , but rest him regularly
JW - superb - when everyone was losing their heads in the 3rd, JW has time and space marks in defence pauses then lace out foot pass.
i just pray that we dont burn these young kids
swans have a well driven team , superb list and a midfield
endeavour was there but no basic skills that lets us down - so what this means is we need to migrate players out and draft in new talent as fast as possible with a new development program driven and funded by the board...
Don't burn out the kids, but get rid of all the senior players ASAP? How does that work?I agree that our seniors are way below par and won't be part of the next great Carlton side (I'm being crazy optimistic here and reckoning there will be one in my lifetime, even though the same 3 or 4 clubs have dominated the AFL for a decade now). But you can't just ditch them all at once and expect a squad with no experience to come good all on it's own; you need some old heads to turn potential into results. GWS have realised this, and we need to not forget it.
good point. this is the essence of one of our problems
We need some hard bodies experienced players to take the load for the young kids
i fear our present situations is that our senior players are not leaders and our kids get hurt
then if we replace the old leaders with moderate aged recruits to protect the kids we are back to square 1 doing a patch up of the list rather than a rebuild
thats why I mentioned elsewhere securing a 24yr old true A grade defender to help JW
we are in a seriously bad position - either way...too young we are gone ..patch up with mid aged recruits we are gone