AGRO wrote:
There was only one mistake with the Judd deal and that was throwing Kennedy in with picks 3 & 20.
We should have held fast at picks 3 & 20 but we blinked.
Ablett went to Gold Coast for Picks 10 & 15.
Ablett's move to GC wasn't a trade. As it was the AFL dudded the Cats massively with the compensation.
If we'd finished bottom in 2007 we'd have held all the cards and could be as aggressive as many wanted us to be.
As it was Richmond still had pick 1 in the pre-season draft and had Judd departed the Eagles for nowt - i can't imagine the Eagles would've allowed that, nor would Judd have left in such circumstances - Richmond would've gladly met any and all demands.
The issue is, had we screwed the Eagles over we'd have entered Collingwood and Essendon** territory in terms of trading. No one would want to deal with us and would hold a grudge over the fact we got a 'bargain' with Judd. Everyone would want their pound of flesh in negotiating with us and the conversation would always go back to,"yeah, but you screwed the Eagles."
We had to do the right thing and we did. Fair trade for all involved, really.
I admire our good guy philosophy.
Look where that has got us since.
Jaksch Jones Dick Tutt ........
If we had Kennedy to straighten us up and built around him and Judd we would have been an attractive club to come to....instead we picked every KP player available in one year Mitchum McCarthy Watson and got duds with everyone when we could have bolstered our midfield.