Synbad wrote:
club29 wrote:
Synbad wrote:
club29 wrote:
Find it hard to blame Ratts for Lucas' development. Ratts really liked Lucas but Lucas' development went off the rails with injury and then just plain bad form. Couldnt kick a drop punt for a season. He is giving it a nudge this year but still on the edge of our best team. Looks a little lost at times and seems confused as to what he is meant to be doing out there. Perhaps clearer instructions will help there. Needs to go harder too.
Collins hasn't had a good run of games also due to injury and bad form.
I am sure everyone agreed Ratts had had enough time to get results and it was time to move him on but some of the reasons people give to put him through the ringer seem a little off to me.
Worst coach since Ian Stewart...... don t worry about defending that guy.
Terrible.. terrible coach..!!!!. and over 5 seasons of his cluelesness....
Noone went forward to any great heights under that Ratts... nobody!!!..... the human glass ceiling
You really dont want that guy in charge of your players and team....its why he is finished as an AFL head coach...
Please... enough of revising history... it makes me feel ill to know some people actually think he was a goodd coach and unlucky.
If his name was Knights he would be getting totally slagged off after a season...

Sorry mate.. noone else hired him as an AFL and wont.. but we ept him for over 5 years...
So lets not pretend right??... nothing worse than pretending Ratten is a desirable coach.. and Sticks is a desirable president...
They wouldnt have those possies for any other well run club.
I find it hard enough to get rid of the bitter taste of him being allowed to be custodian of our team for over 5 years... by another guy who gave him a contract and remains unaccountable in the payout!!!!...
So please dont bring him up like some kind of Carlton martyr.. its sooo wrong!!!!...
hes a good ex player... who got had mates running the club ....and got lucky... !!!!
Thats it!!!
You go on a rant whenever his name is brought up. Noone has said he is a gun coach. Most said it was time to move him on. He copped some crap along the way for tactics that the master coach Malthouse is still using today. The taggers, Gibbs back and shootout footy with poor defending.
I was defending him against the suggestion he stalled Lucas' development. I am not sure Lucas not being able to stick a tackle has to do with Ratts not playing him when he couldn't nail a drop punt a year ago. The Whistler and I use to watch him for the Bullants and were always suprised when one came of the boot properly. A result of his bad hammy and new running gait maybe.
Ratts is gone. Be happy if you think he robbed you of enjoyment of football and get on with enjoying Malthouse for your own sanity. I will get on with things another way.