DocSherrin wrote:
Synbad wrote:
DOC just cos you reckon the club is getting better doesnt mean it is.....
...and because you believe it isn't getting better, doesn't mean it's not...
Synbad wrote:
We got an insight on TWO board directors recently on here,,,,, guys with a real insight into where the club is being steered...
Nothing to be impressed about .....
Well...not to get too technical, but one current board member. True though, it wasn't impressive. My exact words to a fellow board member of his and some staff were 'You can't let that happen again.' My feelings on Ruffy's experiment would probably match yours. Not good.
Synbad wrote:
so again... just cos people talk things up doesnt mean thats the reality at the pointy end that matters.
I didn't come down in the last shower. I've worked with boards for 20 years. At the pointy end we've had a few board members join that are the ilk of businessmen we've been after for a while. We've had a member of the executive removed. I've every right to be enthused by action and personal correspondence with both staff and board member.
Synbad wrote:
There is nothing that suggests these guys know what theyre doing except for a bunch of sackings they had endorsed in the first place
Look to the future. Not the past. Move on. I'm not interested in the stuff ups that were the Spirit of Carlton changeover, the hiring and exit of Robert Hyde, the rotten comms dished up from Coutts, the stuff up of my daughters name on the 'Blue Believer' board that still isn't there despite having paid for it 4 years ago.
I'm even prepared to give Mick a fair go despite the fact that I don't have much time for his manager having worked with/for him. Seeing him in Carlton colors is akin to going to The Cavern Club in Liverpool to hear Paul McCartney play some Beatles songs only to get an 80-minute set of Wings songs. I'm hopeful of witnessing greatness, but I'm well aware it could also be a massive let down.
It's January. The club is moving in the right direction. It needs to do a lot more. There's so much potential don't you think? ....Hey! Look at the fortune cookie I just opened!

I just go on track records.
Not too sure why pretty much the same people have been average for 10 years .. will suddenly grow a new leg.
18 months ago they signed Ratts up for 2 seasons and his assistants... 10 months ago they wanted him gone.
4 months ago they sacked him
installed malthouse and wiley
wiley is development coach AND assistant coach
again no process... (not that i cared after they buggered up the coaching situation by putting ratts in without a process in the first place.....)... but at some stage these guys must go wth a process and must be made accountable
Again...you can overwater the lawn and its just one big bog ....
Just because YOU say its all huny dory doesnt mean it is.........cos its pure guesswork from you.... i have their track record to go by ....
I thinks thats the salient difference between you and i...
Its just average....... has been average ... will be average....