jimmae wrote:
The Rhino wrote:
I'm assuming you didn't read my earlier post - will bring it back up again - given Walker smashed Dangerfield last time around, give him the job again? Armfield to the forward line?
I've glanced at it. I'd prefer to keep Walker forward and I've been of that opinion for close to 3 years. We could use either Walker or Armfield as the defensive forward, but I just want Walker to ensure he's providing pressure when the ball hits the deck. Houlihan could not come back faster; I'd like to have us deploy Armfield in defence/midfield and make Betts & Walker more accountable for their performance.
We can use Lucas on Dangerfield as he can thwart him on the ground & in the air. Or we can keep Carrazzo in if he pleads mercy to Ratten.

Not sure why you've gone so tall?
Agree with your sentiments on Houlihan. Don't feel Walker provides any pressure once the ball hits the deck, as 9/10 he will have attempted to go for mark of the year, and be on his arse.
Be a big call to bring in a borderline inclusion for the purpose of playing on the opposition's best midfielder, I don't think he has the strength to go with him, nor do I think Carrots has what it takes to go with him if he goes forward.
Have gone so tall, as we've struggled with tall forwardlines at Etihad in the past, and think White should be kept in as insurance. At the same time, without Davis, it forces them to play an extra tall down back, their best option for this, Luke Thompson I don't think is ready for senior footy. If we were playing at AAMI, I'd probably advocate the extra small also, but given their fitness issues, I reckon we can cope anyway. Put our best runner in Armfield on at the sub at half time (in an ideal world) and I reckon we'll overrun them.