Effes wrote:
The comments on Bower just show how little Walls actually knows about each player - the guy has struggled with injury for the entire season.
You only have to look at who Walls rated as A-graders on the Geelong list to see how out of touch he is.

Mooney, Ottens, Mackie, Enright A-Graders?
He's been out of touch with the game for a long time now...nice to see him give the club a bake but in terms of substance he is lacking.
Wallsy is clearly measuring the Cats on a different basis than Carlton. At the moment, The following are NOT A-Graders: Corey, Ottens, Mooney, Mackie
The following are NOT B-Graders: Hawkins, Stokes, Byrnes, Wojcinski, Hunt, Rooke.
By this assessment, Carlton’s A-Graders would be: Judd, Murphy, Gibbs, Waite, Simpson, Kreuzer
B Graders: Betts, Bower, Carrazzo, Walker, Russell, Thornton, AJ (no worse than Hunt this season and certainly more productive than Rooke…), Jamison
C Graders: Yarran, Garlett, Fisher, Henderson, Setanta, Johnson, Grigg, Hadley, Warnock, Hampson, Ellard, White.
Having said that, his article about us in The Age is pretty accurate as far as holding the players accountable is concerned. I think as far as talent is concerned he is a little hysterical. We definitely have some holes to plug but we are much closer than he presents - our best team, playing at their best, with an effective gameplan is top-4 competitive. We fall away when any of those factors are not present PLUS we lack the ticker (hardness, resilience, relentlessness) to compete with top 4 CONSISTENTLY. IMO.