Paddycripps wrote:
keogh wrote:
I personally don’t want Clarkson
Not because of what he did to Ian Atkin
Not stopping Fev getting to 100
I reckon he is done as a coach
His record at Hawthorn the last few years tells the tale
The board always go for the big fish
It doesn’t work
I’m beginning to have my doubts about Teague bu why not a coach who is of the right stuff
Surely there is someone who can do a good job
To me it reeks of the past if we get him
My impression of Clarko is he definitely needs a break at the very least
Bolton and Teague were big fish were they?
No they were not. Neither was Brittian or Ratts
But Bolton didn’t see out his contract no coaches have at Carlton in the last 20 years
Teague looks like he won’t last the year
Brittian was replaced by a big fish Pagan who was passed it
Ratten was a newbie. He has been the only successful coach
I was critical of his one style approach but he was sacked for a big fish before he should have been
who sent us backwards in Malthouse
It seems to board can’t get it right
Big fish or small fish
Clarkson has been the best coach in
the last 20 years
Dermott didn’t want him
Piggy did
What I’m saying given the number of coaches assistants included in the AFL system there is bound to be a few real good coaches in waiting
The important thing is the people who select the coach
Some like Dunstall are good at it
Some like Dermott not so
Don’t forget when Clarkson was appointed he had coached Werribee, Central Districts and an assistant at
Port
He was a coach on training wheels
I want the best coach for the Carlton
Teague Clarkson or whoever
It’s up to the board to select the best
They have ducked up that baby the last 20 years