budzy wrote:
Get rid of the mediocre senior softies who will take us nowhere ...
CARE TO NAME NAMES? For what it is worth I'd like to see the younger brigade start to push out Scotland, Stevens and Houlihan but they've got to producer the goods on a regular basis. We need more accountability but we need class as well. I worry with Judd Murphy and Gibbs all in the middle at once that we lack defensive pressure. My initial thoughts on a best 22 - assuming the younger brigade can step up - is:
ARMFIELD JAMISON THORNTON
GIBBS BOWER RUSSELL
SIMPSON CARRAZZO WAITE
GARLETT O'hAILPIN WALKER
KREUZER FEVOLA BETTS
WARNOCK JUDD MURPHY
GRIGG HADLEY JOSEPH YARRAN
I don't particularly like Gibbs off half-back, but without him there we lack quality delivery out of defence. Johnson is not the answer IMO, O'Keeffe may be but is untested, if we leave out Scotland Stevens and Houlihan who else is there? Yarran might be an option, but that is yet to be tested although he has shown a bit in that role in the 2s. Hartlett has great disposal but yet to show he can cut it at the top level and may find himself delisted. Austin's disposal is neat but not elite and he is in my mind next cab off the rank behind the KPP's I've named. So Gibbs to HBF, which also allows room in midfield for a more defensively minded player. If we need more height in defence we have Waite, or for real height O'hAilpin (Kreuzer in an emergency) or for a smaller opponent Walker or even Grigg could fill a KPD role. If we need pace back Simpson, Walker, Grigg, Joseph or Yarran. We have plenty in midfield and bench who can go forward, as well as Gibbs or at a pinch Thornton, whilst Russell and Armfield could do the negating half-forward role, and any number of players can rotate through midfield. Hard tags? - Joseph/Armfield for a small, Russell/Grigg for a bigger type. Carrazzo/Hadley in and under, Waite/Walker bigger body types on ball should relieve Judd of some of the grunt work and must be told to keep his taggers looking over their shoulder.
We have less of a "down-hill skier" midfield, whilst I'd like Judd and Murphy to be more accountable if we surround them with more accountable types and less Stevo/Scoto/Hoops types and rotate any other less accountable types (eg Gibbs, Yarran) on-ball only if Murphy and/or Judd are resting we won't be so exposed by opponents who are prepared to run hard. And if the less elite midfielders aren't prepared to work hard both ways theres a red jumper waiting.
Realistically, we probably need some of the Scotto/Stevo/Hoops experience in the team, but injuries will open up spots I am sure and the 22 I've named above only has 2 really green players - Garlett and Yarran - the others at least have a bit of experience now.
It's an exciting time to be a Blues fan!!!!!!!!!!!!!