Habib wrote:
The players are the best judges on who's the better teams... this result gives me more confidence than any expert, official or tipster out there...
Not really!
2008 Captains Predictions:
Quote:
Which seven other clubs do you think can make this year's top eight? (16 times seven selections)
Geelong (15), Hawthorn (14), St Kilda (14), West Coast (12), Port Adelaide (12), Adelaide (11), Sydney (11), Fremantle (nine), Collingwood (six), Western Bulldogs (three), Brisbane Lions (two), Essendon* (two), North Melbourne (one), Carlton (nil), Melbourne (nil), Richmond (nil).
Which other club is most likely to reach the Grand Final?
Geelong (14), St Kilda (two).
Who do you think will win the 2008 Brownlow Medal?
Gary Ablett, Geelong (six), Chris Judd, Carlton (three), Adam Goodes, Sydney (two), Jonathon Brown, Brisbane Lions (one), Daniel Kerr, West Coast (one), Joel Corey, Geelong (one), Nick Dal Santo, St Kilda (one), Brad Johnson, Western Bulldogs (one).
Who do you think will win the 2008 Coleman Medal?
Jonathan Brown, Brisbane Lions(six), Brendan Fevola, Carlton (five), Matthew Pavlich, Fremantle (two), Lance Franklin, Hawthorn (two), Matthew Lloyd, Essendon* (one).
Who do you think will win the 2008 NAB AFL Rising Star?
Matthew Kreuzer, Carlton (five), Cyril Rioli, Hawthorn (three), Matthew Leuenberger, Brisbane Lions (two), Craig Bird, Sydney (one), Tom Hawkins, Geelong (one), Brad Ebert, West Coast (one), Jarryn Geary, St Kilda (one), Andrejis Everitt, Western Bulldogs (one), James Sellar, Adelaide (one).
Some interesting points - Only Geelong and StKilda were picked to make the grand final.
Although taking out the Brownlow last year by 7 votes after missing the last 2 games, Jimmy Bartel was not nominated by any captain as going back to back Brownlows.
No captain picked either Carlton, Melbourne or Richmond to make the 8
Note - For the questions, it is automatically assumed that each captain believes their side will make the final 8 and play off in the Grand Final.