He's not on the same level as Judd.

Judd is the best - 'A' is the best. Therefore Stevens is B grade

Judd along with Ablett, Franklin, Goodes, Kerr and Brown are in a league of there own for me , which is well above A.
But that's only my opinion.

Yours is valide if you classify Judd as A then i agree Stevens is not in his class.

He was A+ last Saturday.

Ahhhhhhm

Walker's victorian.

_________________
Congratulations CK95

Originally from NSW. Spent the first twelve years of his life as a New South Welshboy.

I might be wrong about this.

But I said All Stars no Allies.

Wasn't Walker and Betts named in the All Stars squad?

_________________
Everyone looks good in Navy Blue

Dont care if he spent the first 12 years of his life in Outer Mongolia.


As long as he spends the next 12 years of his life in a Navy Blue Jumper with a Number 1 on the back of it - I will die a very happy man.


If he wants a contract extension at the end of 12 years - just let me know and I will see what I can do.

_________________
"Hence you will not say that Greeks fight like heroes but that heroes fight like Greeks"?

Winston Churchill

The Duke wrote



I terms of grade of player and potential premiership players in order...

1.Judd superstar of the comp
2.Fevola superstar of the game

3.Waite A grade
4.Walker A grade (kicking issue may drop him to a minus at times)
5.Stevens A grade
6.Scotland A grade

7.Murphy A grade but on the rise
8.Gibbs A grade but on the rise
9.Kreuzer A grade but on the rise
10.Simpson A grade but on the rise

11.Carrazzo B+ grade (due to kicking issue)
12.Hadley B+ grade
13.Bentick B+ grade

14.Jamison B Grade on the rise
15.Thornton B grade
16.Houlihan B grade
17.Betts B grade and rising
18.Bower B grade and rising



19.Armfield Big upside
20. Setanta Big upside
21.Hammer Big upside
22.Grigg Big upside
23.Anderson Big upside

I don't know where to place Fisher. One trick pony till he gets his kicking right or he's played close to goals (every game) then he may be classed as a B grader at FP.

Wiggins and Banno I'll put in the 'grunt' department. In top 22 till those with upside replace them.

Russell, Hartlett, Austin, Edwards have a lot to prove before displacing abovementioned. Edwards imo could be the wildcard.

Disclaimer: I will change my mind on the field every day. It's a week to week proposition.

Nevertheless we have a great young squad moving forward.

_________________
Everyone looks good in Navy Blue