Donstuie wrote:
The sad thing is that guys like Thornton, Saddington, O'Halpin, Lappin and Waite have all shown at different times that they can be capable defenders (Lappin was an All-Australian at half-back a few years ago). So it makes the statistic even more galling when technically we should have a pretty good defence but either the confidence or the gameplan is letting them down. It's clear Pagan has no respect for the work defenders do, always going on about how attacking at all costs is SO much better for our players.
Impossible to have a defence function properly when a different group of six players are positioned down there week after week. I'd hazard a guess and say that Thornton and maybe Scotland would be the only players that have played in our backline every game this year (oh, and Gibbs of course), the rest get shuffled around continually.
How Pagan expects the defence to learn each others games and gel together is beyond me.
My main interests in Carlton games are at the first bounce, because:
a) scores are level, and
b) I'm curious to see how Pagan has positioned all the players this week