The Tyrant wrote:
therubbernub wrote:
Tyrant as for this "more adversarial crap" Feeling defensive are we? Not sure why you decide to play the man perhaps you have no arguments
Unlike your original post, which... um..... how was that different again?

Nub, let me ask you a question. How many carlton supporters, on this site or others, WANT to lose? How many, do you reckon? 2%? 5%? None?
come on, mate, answer the question.
Tyrant for the last week there has been so much garbage spewing forth from people who wanted to be on record as saying "our season is over"
I could not be bothered debating with them at the time because I knew that a win this week would mean that we were very close to being in the eight. How could anyone say our season was over after 5 rounds? Especially when we were never too far away in any game and we had one win and a draw to last years premiers.
I was not saying that anyone wanted us to lose- why ask the question. What I was questioning was peoples willingness to write us off after
1 A 20 point loss to the Roos (undefeated)
2 A win over the bombers
3 A 20 point loss to the Pies (who always lift against us)
4 A draw against the reigning premiers
5 A 19 point loss to a top 8 team on the rebound at home, when we were travelling for the 2nd week.
Just because we played a scrappy game does not mean we a re a bad team. Ok it wasnt the best game in the world and it was only the Hawks but you can only beat your opposition. How many people remember in the good old days when we were the most skilled side going around, that some of our danger games was against the scragging type teams - those that dragged you down to their (less skilled) level. Thats why the game was not a great spectacle.
Yes we were lucky to win BUT we showed courage and Tenacity and came back when it looked like Hodge , Osborne , Mitchel and Crawford were going to take us to the cleaners. To be able to run the game out like we did particularly after playing in adelaide and Perth, was a real credit to the side.
You see Tyrant I look at a side and ask myself how good can this side be, while others are still asking How shit are We?