If you could pick one player from each club to come to Carlton, who do you think would be the best fit. Here's how I'd go:

Adelaide - Ben Rutten - one of the best full backs in the league and what we are sorely lacking, a fullback to take the bigger full forwards, would be a perfect fit

Brisbane - Jamie Charman - young, athletic ruckman

Collingwood - James Clement - steady backman, always can be counted on and provides leadership - can play tall or small

Essendon* - Brent Stanton - young midfielder who knows how to get the ball and disposes of it well

Fremantle - Obvious choice Pavlich, but only as a midfielder (unless you turn him into a CHB), otherwise I'd go for

Geelong - Corey Enright - dash, pace and skill off of half back

Hawthorn - Sam Mitchell - in and under midfielder, full of class

Kangaroos - Daniel Harris - see above, but to a lesser extent

Melbourne - Cameron Bruce (class, class, class) but has a great work ethic and a great tackler

Port Adelaide - Shaun Burgoyne - silky smooth operator

Richmond - Troy Simmonds - would solve our ruck deficiences single-handedly

St Kilda - Nick Dal Santo or a wildcard with Sam Fisher - obviously Dal Satno brings class and pace, Fisher is a very handy third backman (though not the priority without having a full-back)

Sydney - Adam Goodes - midfielder, key position, ruckman - take your pick

West Coast - Judd, Cox - tough call, what do we need more? I guess you'd have to go Judd

Western Bulldogs - Daniel Cross - guy is a superstar and I'd call him to win a Brownlow at some stage when Westy stops stealing his votes

one is not enough for us.
can't go past Judd.

Adelaide - Simon Goodwin

Brisbane - Jonathon Brown

Collingwood - James Clement

Essendon* - Mathew Lloyd

Fremantle - Mathew Pavlich

Geelong - Paul Chapman

Hawthorn - Luke Hodge

Kangaroos - Jesse Smith

Melbourne - Travis Johnson

Port Adelaide - Shaun Burgoyne

Richmond - Nathan Brown

St Kilda - Nick Reiwoldt

Sydney - Adam Goodes

West Coast - Chris Judd

Western Bulldogs - Ryan Griffen

Adelaide - Ben Rutten
Brisbane - Simon Black
Collingwood - James Clement
Essendon* - Patrick Ryder
Fremantle - Matthew Pavlich
Geelong - Joel Corey
Hawthorn - Sam Mitchell
Kangaroos - Daniel Wells
Melbourne - Jeff White
Port Adelaide - Chad Cornes
Richmond - Brett Deledio
St Kilda - Brendon Goddard
Sydney - Brett Kirk
West Coast - Ben Cousins
Bulldogs - Adam Cooney

_________________
*(grow - fun - gah)

Yeah but whatabout your whataboutism.

Adelaide - Graeme Johncock (closely followed by Mattner, or Perrie)

Brisbane - Jonathon Brown

Collingwood - James Clement

Essendon* - Who else....Courtney Johns! Seriously, though...Stanton.

Fremantle - Haselby

Geelong - Paul Chapman

Hawthorn - Luke Hodge

Kangaroos - Hale

Melbourne - Travis Johnson

Port Adelaide - Danyle Pearce

Richmond - Deledio

St Kilda - Nick Reiwoldt

Sydney - Adam Schneider (followed by Keneally, Goodes, and a smoky like Malceski)

West Coast - Chris Judd, Adam Hunter

Western Bulldogs - Adam Cooney (Followed by Giansiracusa, Nathan Eagleton and Brett Montgomery)

_________________
And so while others miserably pledge themselves to the pursuit of ambition and brief power, I will be stretched out in the shade, singing.

ohhhhh for each team, LOL.
well then

Adelaide - Ben Rutten
Brisbane - Jonathon Brown
Collingwood - Didak, even though i hate the prick.
Essendon* - Stanton
Fremantle - Pavlich
Geelong - Chapman
Hawthorn - Hodge
North - Wells
Melbourne - Bruce
Port - Shaun Burgoyne
Richmond - Deledio
St Kilda - Riewoldt
Sydney - Goodes
West Coast - Judd
Western Bulldogs - Griffen

Adelaide- Mattner

Brisbane- Simon Black- still one of the best midfielders in the league (was gona say Brown but we probably couldnt fit him in our forward line...

Coll- Dids

Ess- nobody really-- I suppose Stanton

Fre- Would love a Josh Carr- we need a small little bastard who can also play some awesome footy..

Geelong- Scarlett/ Ablett

Haw- mm.. where to start- probably Mitchell just ahead of Roughead who I think will be a beauty..

Melbourne- Bruce

Kangas- Wells- just the type of player we need

Port- Chad Cornes- can play anywhere

Rich- Deledio

St K- Dal Santo

Sydney- Jude Bolton- favourite player in the comp

West Coast- My boy Juddy

adelaide - a.mcleod - even if its for only 1 year
brisbane - j.brown
collingwood - d.thomas
Essendon* - j.laycock
fremantle - p.haselby
geelong - t.hawkins
hawthorn - l.hodge
melbourne - c.bruce
nth melbourne - d.wells
port - burgoynes
richmond - a.raines
st kilda - n.riewoldt
sydney - b.hall
west coast - c.judd
western buldogs - d.cross

_________________
I'm Rick James B***ch, go and have sex with Charlie Murphy

Adelaide - Gibbs or Ricciuto

Brisbane - Wood.

Collingwood - Didak

Essendon* - Hille

Fremantle - Pavlich

Geelong - Ablett jnr.

Hawthorn - Franklin

Kangaroos - Wells

Melbourne - Brock Mclean

Port Adelaide - S.Burgoyne

Richmond - Deledio

St Kilda - Goddard

Sydney - Goodes

West Coast - Gardiner then Judd

Western Bulldogs - Johnson if he was younger but I'll take Griffen

ADELAIDE: ben rutten
BRISBANE: jonathon brown
COLLINGWOOD: josh fraser
Essendon*: brent stanton
FREMANTLE: matthew pavlich
GEELONG: matthew scarlett
HAWTHORN: luke hodge
KANGAROOS: daniel wells
MELBOURNE: brock mclean
PORT: chad cornes
RICHMOND: brett deledio
SYDNEY: adam goodes
ST.KILDA: nick riewoldt
WEST COAST: chris judd
WESTERN BULLDOGS: adam cooney

_________________
Last edited by true_blue3 on Mon Sep 26, 1981 5:07 pm; edited 92 times in total

Adelaide - Rutten
Brisbane - Brown
Collingwood - Maguire
Essendon* - pick 2
Fremantle - Pavlich
Geelong - Gary Yableeeeeeeeeeeeeeet Jr
Hawthorn - Hodge
Kangaroos - Wells
Melbourne - McLean
Port Adelaide - Jr Burger
Richmond - Deledio
St Kilda - Riewoldt
Sydney - Goodes
West Coast - Cox
Western Bulldogs - Eade

Adelaide - Goodwin
Brisbane - Brown
Collingwood - Fraser
Essendon* - Watson
Fremantle - Pavlich
Geelong - G Ablett Jr
Hawthorn - Franklin
Kangaroos - Wells
Melbourne - McLean
Port Adelaide - C Cornes
Richmond - Deledio
St Kilda - Goddard
Sydney - Goodes
West Coast - Judd
Western Bulldogs - Cooney

Adelaide - Ben Rutten
Brisbane - Simon Black
Collingwood - Dane Swan
Essendon* - Brent Stanton
Fremantle - Matthew Pavlich
Geelong - Gary Ablett Jr
Hawthorn - Sam Mitchell
Kangaroos - Daniel Wells
Melbourne - Brock McLean
Port Adelaide - Brendan Lade
Richmond - Brett Deledio
St Kilda - Nick Riewoldt
Sydney - Adam Goodes
West Coast - Chris Judd
Western Bulldogs - Adam Cooney

Essendon* - Hanson

I am going to change my list slightly. What I am going to do is select one player from every other club and then add it to 10 Carlton players to put together a team + emergencies. Here we go...

Adelaide - Rutten
Brisbane - Black
Collingwood - Fraser
Essendon* - Watson
Fremantle - Sandilands
Geelong - G Ablett Jr
Hawthorn - Franklin
Kangaroos - Wells
Melbourne - McLean
Port Adelaide - C Cornes
Richmond - Deledio
St Kilda - Goddard
Sydney - Goodes
West Coast - Judd
Western Bulldogs - Cooney

The 10 Carlton players: Fevola, Scotland, Whitnall, Murphy, Walker, Stevens, Thornton, Simpson, Houlihan and Gibbs

B: Walker, Rutten, Thornton
HB: Goddard, C. Cornes, Deledio
C: Simpson, Black, Goodes
HF: McLean, Franklin, Cooney
F: Fraser, Fevola, G. Ablett Jnr
FOLL: Sandilands, Judd, Murphy
INT: Stevens, Whitnall, Wells, Gibbs
EMERG: Scotland, Watson, Houlihan

Cool.....

Glenelg: Gibbs

_________________
Love Cricket? Love me

Adelaide - Ben Rutten
Brisbane - Simon Black
Collingwood - James Clement
Essendon* - Angus Monfries
Fremantle - Matthew Pavlich
Geelong - Gary Ablett
Hawthorn - Sam Mitchell
Kangaroos - Daniel Harris
Melbourne - Brock McLean
Port Adelaide - Danyle Pearce
Richmond - Brett Deledio
St Kilda - Brendon Goddard
Sydney - Leaping Leo
West Coast - Chris Judd
Bulldogs - Daniel Giansiracusa

Adelaide - Riccuito
Brisbane - Browny
Collingwood - Thomas
Essendon* - Nathan Lovett
Fremantle - Matthew Pavlich
Geelong - Gary Ablett Jr
Hawthorn - Sam Mitchell
Kangaroos - Daniel Wells
Melbourne - Aaron Davey
Port Adelaide - Danyle Pearce
Richmond - Simmonds
St Kilda - Matt Maguire
Sydney - Goodes
West Coast - Legs of Judd, the guts of Cousins and the brain of Kerr
Bulldogs - Brad Johnson

_________________
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pw60JKnwy2g

get Judd and clone him

_________________
Ich bein ein Carltonian