Ah but Synners I thought he had no opponents...and no role...

_________________
Congratulations CK95

And in 2005 he had no future

_________________
In WADA we trust

What a bunch of great supports we have 10 pages of bagging Lance.

Lance has stuck it up most of his critics this year instead of 10 pages of support all we get is Carlton supports fighting weather or not we should trade him.

Lance is the winner the CFC is lucky to have a loyal club man.

Its time for people to support Lance he will be at the club for a minumum of another 3 years and will be the next Captain of Carlton.

He is a great leader on and off the field.

Who knows - if we recruit Gardiner, some posters might get off Lance's back and start bagging MG.

_________________
“It is a state of mind, a system of belief, a way of seeing the world, a deep faith that, because you are Carlton, you belong to something great.” - Mike Fitzpatrick articulating what Out of the Blue means.

Ego's, Blueboy. Many posters have lost all credibility after they slagged off this great Carlton player. They now can't accept it and are cluching at straws to justify their slander.

They're not alone, some in the media were very wrong too.

_________________
end of message

Well obviously its clear he doesnt as he just lets his opponent unaccounted for.. and he needs his opponents HANDPICKED for him!!

His fitness went down and Rocca smashed him, when Whitnall had previously done a good job on him earlier in the year.. There are many examples! His first half was good but he really went down the gurgler in the 2nd half!

Might have something to do with Whitnall's diet and once again not taking the issue SERIOUSLY!! Well, he can enjoy his Krispy Kremes now!!!

_________________
In other news.. Melbourne has stepped up its Bid for Whitnall.. offering a 2nd round pick and it's promise to Whitnall to offer him a spot up forward with a Mega box of Krispy Kremes!

My guess would be......

< Stevens Tagger

_________________
The most terrifying words in the English language are: I'm from the government and I'm here to help.

Ronald Reagan

A well thought out and constructed post BlueBlood. Keep em coming.

killpies -

_________________
Congratulations CK95

Facts would be nice why let that in the way for a good laugh. Taking cheap shot only gets you so far.

K H P M HO T
Round 1 02/04/2006 Melbourne 10 5 15 9 0 1
Round 2 08/04/2006 Fremantle 18 4 22 4 0 1
Round 3 15/04/2006 Sydney Swans 9 5 14 2 1 1
Round 4 21/04/2006 Hawthorn 18 3 21 16 2 2
Round 5 28/04/2006 Richmond 18 4 22 12 0 1
Round 6 07/05/2006 Collingwood 16 10 26 17 1 1
Round 7 14/05/2006 Essendon* 13 4 17 6 1 0
Round 8 21/05/2006 St Kilda 19 8 27 15 1 0
Round 9 27/05/2006 Adelaide 9 7 16 6 0 0
Round 10 04/06/2006 Port Adelaide 21 9 30 8 3
Round 11 11/06/2006 West Coast Eagles 15 6 21 9 0 3 0 0 0 0




Round 12 23/06/2006 Kangaroos 10 5 15 5 0
Round 13 01/07/2006 Brisbane Lions 14 3 17 6 0
Round 14 08/07/2006 Geelong 14 9 23 7 2 0
Round 15 16/07/2006 Western Bulldogs 10 6 16 7
Round 16 22/07/2006 Essendon* 12 10 22 8 6
Round 17 30/07/2006 Fremantle 11 4 15 4 0
Round 18 05/08/2006 Melbourne 9 9 18 10 1
Round 19 13/08/2006 Hawthorn 11 3 14 2 1
Round 20 20/08/2006 Richmond 16 7 23 12 1
Round 21 27/08/2006 Collingwood 9 3 12 11 1
Round 22 03/09/2006 Sydney Swans 2 6 8 1 0

But stats can be meaningless! Like Synbad said, I wonder how many goals Whitnall had kicked on him..??

His tackle count is another blight on his performance which shows a lack of accountability.

Sure, Whitnall was OK this year.. but far from our Best!

The bad things evens out alot of the good things he does on the field..

Trade him to the dees for a 2nd round pick or if theyre desperate enough, a round 1 pick! Now thats forward thinking and looking to the future!

WHITNALL is a has-been!

_________________
In other news.. Melbourne has stepped up its Bid for Whitnall.. offering a 2nd round pick and it's promise to Whitnall to offer him a spot up forward with a Mega box of Krispy Kremes!

Typical crap being spouted by the anti-Whitnall element who are falling over themselves to protect their own reputations as they wrote him off at the start of the year.

There's a case for saying Fev had a better year than Lance but after that, thats about it. Scotland was ok, Simpson good (particularly in the second half of the year), Murphy promising. He's a deserved best and fairest winner and won't be traded.

Perhaps Lappin is more deserving of your vitriol ...

_________________
In WADA we trust

Because we choose to look at the game and think lateraly and not just at meaningless stats!

Whitnall was GOOD, but i would say Fev, Scotland and Simpson had much better years for the whole 22 rounds than Whitnall.

Whitnall was good, but like he always has been was Spasmodic! He would have 4 or 5 goals kicked on him during certain games, but then the media would have the audacity to put him in Carltons best because he took a few MARKS!

A very overrated footballer is Big Red!

_________________
In other news.. Melbourne has stepped up its Bid for Whitnall.. offering a 2nd round pick and it's promise to Whitnall to offer him a spot up forward with a Mega box of Krispy Kremes!

BB101 - How did you rate Fev's 1%s all the time, not occasionally, and how much did Scotland's possessions hurt the opposition (after he had run around in circles several times and kicked it 15 metres laterally). Not saying they weren't good, but both had deficiencies, and Scotto is not that tight as a half back flanker either. And it is not just about goals - Jezza 110 in 1970 - no b&f. Fev was great and if he improves his chasing and tackling over the whole match and not just in patches he might win next year.

What are on about??

I thought Fevs 1 %s were terrific for the year, except perhaps the last 2 or 3 games he dropped off.. Fev is one of our hardest workers on the field.. its when he does his block (which happens less these days) that people single him out!

Scotland was terrific and was our most consistent player. Far more than Lance! Whitnall may have had a fair impact on some games, however due to his diet, he cant keep up that decent level of performance for more than half a season!

Still has some work to do in the fitness stakes!!

Trade him to melbourne or geelong!

_________________
In other news.. Melbourne has stepped up its Bid for Whitnall.. offering a 2nd round pick and it's promise to Whitnall to offer him a spot up forward with a Mega box of Krispy Kremes!

Thanks for the stats BlueBlood-101 to bad it doesnt help your cause.

You talk alot of crap Carlton will never trade Lance so get over it. He will be Carltons next captain.

And you have some nerve calling our best and fairest a has been.

He still has a lot to offer to the club weather you like it or not.

That would actually be planning for the future....

_________________
"You are being watched. The government has a secret system. A machine that spies on you every hour of every day. I know because I built it." - Finch

I agree with you on this one Effes..

_________________
In other news.. Melbourne has stepped up its Bid for Whitnall.. offering a 2nd round pick and it's promise to Whitnall to offer him a spot up forward with a Mega box of Krispy Kremes!

I've got a mate who's a Melbourne supporter. He was telling me about how they were planning for the future. I think the year was 1991.

Lance 6th on CFC 1%ers per game.

Scotland 18th.

Fev 23rd.

You need to be carfeful when using subjective perceptions which can be checked via reference to actual statistics.

For reference, Lance had the same no of tackles per game as Bret Thornton ... funny about that.

Thats because Lance is in more of the ACTION!!.. Hmm, funny that.. perhaps its because they are both in the backline..

I'll defend Fev because i've seen him many times this year chase and do the 1%ers.. The thing is, he isnt always in the action and where the ball is... he has to run to where the ball is in play... Ive seen him run a long way to make tackles many times.. He's certainly good value in that area now, perhaps could do with more stamina, thats all!

Lance is a spare man in defence! I'm not saying he's unaccountable, im saying he is unaccountable on his OPPONENT!

But thats ok, i wont flog this 1 to death.. thats my view and we'll leave it at that! I just think this season he's been given too much credit!

He's been a good player for us at times, but too inconsistent!

_________________
In other news.. Melbourne has stepped up its Bid for Whitnall.. offering a 2nd round pick and it's promise to Whitnall to offer him a spot up forward with a Mega box of Krispy Kremes!