Happy with all that Doc. I'm disappointed for Cincotta as I thought he might help, but at 28 I don't think we need to carry him.

Regards Cazzesman

We’ve got a bunch of young, pliable minds on the list that can only benefit from being around a bloke with a story like Cincotta’s.

I think a couple on Doc list have zero trade value

Sent from my SM-F956B using Tapatalk

Some great differences of opinion here. Here's hoping you get the opportunity to come on here and say 'I told you so'.

But the Carlton of 2023 is long gone and so has the playing style. The game evolves. Voss needs to prove to Wright that he can evolve too.

Here's what I'd do. By gutting the list, I mean I want these changes made. It's Carlton, so it's unlikely to happen. I'll be happy with just McKay and Silvagni gone to be honest.

 Adam Saad = Delist/Retire
 Alex Cincotta = Delist
 Blake Acres = Trade
 Elijah Hollands = Delist
 Flynn Young = Delist
 Francis Evans = Delist
 Harry McKay = 1st Rnd return
 Jack Silvagni = 2nd Rnd return
 Jaxon Binns = Trade
 Jesse Motlop = Trade
 Mitch McGovern = Delist
 Orazio Fantasia = Delist
 Sam Docherty = Retired
 Tom De Koning = 1st Rnd return

* I doubt Saad can do another pre-season. Hopefully he does the right thing and retires. Pretty sure he'll just jog for his cash though.
* Elijah's departure won't cost us anything. Hopefully the locker is already empty.
* An Acres trade doesn't free up cap space, but you've seen his best. More wingers coming through.
* The club won't get much for Binns and/or Motlop but these players aren't in our best 25.

Harry McKay will not improve at Carlton. You've seen his best here. Trade him while you can and there are buyers.

Backline talls in 2026 are Weitering, Haynes, O'Farrell and Dean. You don't need an injury-ridden JSOS/McGovern on $600k+.

The club needs to get creative. They'll have to bundle selections for the 2026 draft to get Cody Walker - but the ability to trade 2027 selections this year could be the impetus they need to at least pretend they know what they're doing.

Cripps still has two more years left on his contract. He looks like a Carlton-lifer, but I'd see if West Coast wanted a playing mentor for that midfield group. Like McKay - there's no improvement coming from Cripps. You've seen his best.

And in case you're wondering - yes, I'm signing Kemp to a one-year deal. He's only 24.

Owen Leonard
@owenleonard_
Jack Silvagni might’ve played his last game for Carlton, with Michael Voss from Optus Stadium revealing he’s set to miss the rest of the season.

The @CarltonFC coach also not happy with Craig McRae publicly detailing the Silvagni meeting.

On @CollingwoodFC coach Craig McRae admitting to Silvagni meeting:

“It’d unusual for a coach to announce something like that … it’s not something we would do.”

Michael Voss is all class .

If Carlton were to get a premiership player from another club I’d like Vlastuin.

Harry McKay will not improve at Carlton. You've seen his best here. Trade him while you can and there are buyers.

The club needs to get creative.