sinbagger wrote:
bondiblue wrote:
sinbagger wrote:
Do we need three talls in defence for this weekend? Probably better off giving Wilson a run, we need to keep Kemp forward.
Ideally Saad replaces Guv.
As far as tall defenders required, its for the folllowing:
Caminiti 196 was injured and we find out if he's fit to play this week
Membrey 188 has found a bit of form lately.
Sharman 193 is a strong mark and kicked a couple last week
Owens is 191 and a high leaping forward
Wood 192 went forward last week too
If Young plays FB on Caminiti, Weiters can take on 2nd KPD role on Sharman.
You can see from the above we still need cover for another tall and if Gov is out, it may well be Kemp, if Harry returns.
If not....Marchbank is back, but he's not in the form he was in last years Finals series.
Its their smalls that do the most damage on the scoreboard Higgins Wilson Butler and Steele.
Dom Akeui is 194cm and is fit, just sayin…….
watch him now do a hammy at training....

but i'd be tempted to give him a go if mcgrumpy doesnt get up, and tell him to clean up a few blokes
19 on the injury list, but i didnt see williams, so thats kinda a positive
i wouldnt rush saad in, but knowing carlton, we will - play billy wilson as another running flanker and move binns forward if no mcgovern or akuei. i wouldnt play marchbank at all, he would be a liability i feel, too much time away from the game uunfortunately
curnow a test, if he is fit, i'd play him and tell him not to move from the goal square and let coleman kemp be the main man
i was really wrapteded with kemps game last week
whole game for moir and motlop sub
i'm amazed acres isnt on the injury list as well, it really did look like his shoulders were troubling him a lot on sunday