FarmerBlue wrote:
bondiblue wrote:
Its time to get the band together for Finals.
I expect Pitto- TDK is Vossy's preference (and mine during Finals) to be back as business as usual.
I was impressed to see Harry pushed into the ruck, to see what happens (like Vossy said). I don't want to see that again during Finals.
I want 2 KPF's: a CHF and a FF, all the time, and we have Harry and Charlie to do that. So do it!
I notice on footy forums and in conversation there's a real preference to get Boyd back over Fisher to play defense. I'm really disappointed Boyd wasn't given game time in the last 3 weeks, like [url]all[/url] the other players (including depth) have enjoyed. Fisher was never going to be a loose player in defense during Finals. It does not happen.
Kempy wasn't great, and have felt all along he's been playing well, but is still serving his apprenticeship (developing). Ive enjoyed watching marchbank improve by the week and looked good when he came back on.
Weiters will be free to play, maybe pay a fine.
I'm assuming Acres will be right to play.
Cripps - Dow
Docherty - Hollands
Pittonet - Fogarty
Boyd - Fisher
Motlop - Durdin
Marchbank - Kemp
If Acres doesn't get up in 2 weeks, Hollands is in the team.
Sub Kemp.
Emergency Dow Hollands Fogarty
Dow, Kemp and Hollands unlucky.
I couldn't disagree more about Dow & Kemp
Kemp has been very good and Dow has been so important the last 6-8 weeks. He add some run and dash that Cripps Heweet don't have. Allows us to use Walsh and/or Doc on a Wing or even forward
Midifeld dominance is the key. Cripps Hewett Cerra Walsh & Dow as our core is our stength
Marchbank has done nothing to earn a spot and his disposal is poor
I didnt say Kemp has been playing badly. I dont think he played well yesterday, whereas Marchbank didnt play well last week, but looked good yesterday.
I'm going with experience for the next Final. Both good players. In the end I don't mind either way. I will leave that to Vossy.
Just because you keep saying Marchbank hasn't earned a spot, Voss keeps selecting him. Must be something in that. Marchbank's kicking yesterday was fantastic. I don't know why you would say it was poor. Some of those long passes....wow. How many intercepts did Marchbank have in 37% game time? Was he really as bad as you say? Was Kempy better than Marchbank yesterday? Maybe I missed something.
Its going to be hard to fit in the squad of 30 who all (except Boyd) have seen a bit of game time in the last month.
It will be interesting to see where the 'undroppables' Dow and Fisher are picked to play, if they are. Dow was good. Fisher has been, well, a spare in defense. But he's a fan fave because of his stats.
At this stage, we are all right with our teams, till the teams are selected.
I agree on Kemp. I thought he was poor yesterday and has been OK of recent. Personally, I thought Marchbank showed more yesterday and I'd retain him over Kemp. McGovern had the Greene match up most of the day but it was a poor call by the MC. Newman played him beautifully last time and they didn't follow up with it.
A few of the backline match ups were poor at times yesterday. Hamill needs to do better.
I'd bring in Boyd for Fisher, retain Cincotta.
Login
Register
FAQ
Search
