R22: Carlton v Melbourne (Post match Discussion)

Blue Vain · **Joined:** Mon Feb 28, 2005 10:35 am **Posts:** 18363

dannyboy wrote:

bluehammer wrote:

AGRO wrote:

Strutted through Altona Gate Shopping Centre this morning with my Carlton cap on - thinking I’m cock of the walk.

:lol:

Well a few hours later I strutted through Altona Gate shopping centre with my cock out.

Wins do strange things.

did anyone notice?

It was a cold day

SurreyBlue · **Joined:** Mon Feb 28, 2005 8:32 am **Posts:** 11013

Blue Vain wrote:

dannyboy wrote:

bluehammer wrote:

AGRO wrote:

Strutted through Altona Gate Shopping Centre this morning with my Carlton cap on - thinking I’m cock of the walk.

:lol:

Well a few hours later I strutted through Altona Gate shopping centre with my cock out.

Wins do strange things.

did anyone notice?

It was a cold day

Fenwick Snap · **Joined:** Fri Aug 17, 2012 12:00 pm **Posts:** 741

How good was that? Two heart attacks in two hours.

At the G watching an intense but understandably underappreciated opening quarter while checking phone updates and giving up on glancing at distant TV screens. A Matildas-Blues double act.

Was disappointed with our three-point lead at the quarter after totally dominating, but somehow we found the energy to forge a lead in the third and again in the fourth. Despite our inefficiency in the first, however, our intent might have given the Dees just a little pause, even if they outthunk us for a while.

That was a win for the ages and I hope we can keep building. I'm expecting a flat patch next week but I don't care as long as we keep finding ways to win - and we are finding different ways.

Okay...yes, it was touched, and it should have been a free to Marchbank, so it should have been a five-point win. Next...

Umpiring was roughly equal, if at times somewhat atrocious. Cuningham's 'sling' tackle has to be the slowest, most carefully constructed bubble wrap I have ever seen, and I think they were just too bamboozled by Cincotta's tactic to award a trip or tunnel or whatever at the end there, and glad the Dees got caught for some of their litany of throws, even if the scoreboard video gods decided to highlight Dow's escape instead. Whatever.

Apart from Marchie's match-saver, take a squiz at the crucial spoil by TDK in THAT pack from the boundary kick - a pair of Demon hands were about to plant themselves on the pill. Loads of moments like these, and we weathered the storm against an opposition with possibly the best combo of smarts and toughness we've encountered so far this year. Gotta be happy with that.

Cripps in the last... Owies determined to slot that last-term opener... Pitto and TDK nullifying the dynamic duo... Mr Underneath-the-Radar Hewitt all game long... a multi-pronged, besieged yet triumphant backline... etc etc...

Man, that was a night and a half...

More wins, please, but I'm not sure how much my heart can take.

bender · **Posted:** Mon Aug 14, 2023 3:37 am

bondiblue wrote:

bender wrote:

Just got back from the swimming pool, 35 degrees in Lanzarote. Watched the last two minutes replay, that was not touched, so suck it Melbourne. What happened to doc? Did I miss much? Cripps seemed happy. Were we lucky, even though we got a few deliberate out of bounds?

You are in Paradise.

I will pm you for more info re Lanzarote.

You missed more than Lanzarote at the G. Did you hear them? I did on TV, so you must have.

Any time Bondi

bluehammer · **Posted:** Mon Aug 14, 2023 7:43 am

dannyboy wrote:

bluehammer wrote:

AGRO wrote:

Strutted through Altona Gate Shopping Centre this morning with my Carlton cap on - thinking I’m cock of the walk.

:lol:

Well a few hours later I strutted through Altona Gate shopping centre with my cock out.

Wins do strange things.

did anyone notice?

Nah was well hidden under my guts

missnaut · **Posted:** Mon Aug 14, 2023 7:48 am

I've watched the replay, and the last two minutes several times and I still get horribly nervous.

camel · **Posted:** Mon Aug 14, 2023 10:01 am

bosman wrote:

8 down, 6 more to go..

camel · **Posted:** Mon Aug 14, 2023 10:05 am

rhino27 wrote:

daggs001 wrote:

Thankfully the goal umpire called the Marchbank incident touched. Was always going to be hard to overturn his decision once called touched. The system working as it should. Plenty of fuss in the media about nothing.

Yep and no mention of fact that goal umpire was in perfect position. About a metre from the action, no players obstructing his view. He called it touch and there is nothing to indicate otherwise.

Marchbank also immediately appealed to the goal ump to say he touched the ball. Obviously that's not concrete evidence either way, but it definitely adds to the vibe that he genuinely got some part of his body to the ball.

…regardless…

What does the scoreboard say!

rhino27 · **Joined:** Fri Mar 11, 2005 9:58 pm **Posts:** 4299

camel wrote:

rhino27 wrote:

daggs001 wrote:

Thankfully the goal umpire called the Marchbank incident touched. Was always going to be hard to overturn his decision once called touched. The system working as it should. Plenty of fuss in the media about nothing.

Yep and no mention of fact that goal umpire was in perfect position. About a metre from the action, no players obstructing his view. He called it touch and there is nothing to indicate otherwise.

Marchbank also immediately appealed to the goal ump to say he touched the ball. Obviously that's not concrete evidence either way, but it definitely adds to the vibe that he genuinely got some part of his body to the ball.

…regardless…

What does the scoreboard say!

To counteract all that, monga Lloyd said his "gut feel" is it was a goal.
I think that overrides what the goal umpire in a perfect position saw or what Caleb feel touch his fingers.

camel · **Posted:** Mon Aug 14, 2023 10:33 am

Yep, a former Essendon* player has a gut feel that is disadvantageous to Carlton.

I'm shocked to be sitting here, really.

Sidefx · **Joined:** Thu Sep 21, 2017 1:55 pm **Posts:** 7406

camel wrote:

:lol:

Yep, a former Essendon** player has a gut feel that is disadvantageous to Carlton.

I'm shocked to be sitting here, really.

Clearly had is pants pulled up too high for too long, it's affected his mental and gut feel capacity.

missnaut · **Posted:** Mon Aug 14, 2023 11:10 am

I love all these nuffies coming out and saying it was a goal based on absolute @#$%&! all.

camel wrote:

rhino27 wrote:

daggs001 wrote:

Thankfully the goal umpire called the Marchbank incident touched. Was always going to be hard to overturn his decision once called touched. The system working as it should. Plenty of fuss in the media about nothing.

Yep and no mention of fact that goal umpire was in perfect position. About a metre from the action, no players obstructing his view. He called it touch and there is nothing to indicate otherwise.

Marchbank also immediately appealed to the goal ump to say he touched the ball. Obviously that's not concrete evidence either way, but it definitely adds to the vibe that he genuinely got some part of his body to the ball.

…regardless…

What does the scoreboard say!

Watched the replay and the goal umpire says it touched his right arm.

Wojee · **Joined:** Mon Feb 28, 2005 8:17 am **Posts:** 35287

Opposition fans are pretty funny at the moment. I like that it gives them something else to bleat about instead of "Free kick Curnow" :lol:

CK95 · **Posted:** Mon Aug 14, 2023 12:02 pm

It was touched. Mainly because I don't like Petracca

rhino27 · **Joined:** Fri Mar 11, 2005 9:58 pm **Posts:** 4299

missnaut wrote:

I love all these nuffies coming out and saying it was a goal based on absolute @#$%&! all.

camel wrote:

rhino27 wrote:

daggs001 wrote:

Thankfully the goal umpire called the Marchbank incident touched. Was always going to be hard to overturn his decision once called touched. The system working as it should. Plenty of fuss in the media about nothing.

Yep and no mention of fact that goal umpire was in perfect position. About a metre from the action, no players obstructing his view. He called it touch and there is nothing to indicate otherwise.

Marchbank also immediately appealed to the goal ump to say he touched the ball. Obviously that's not concrete evidence either way, but it definitely adds to the vibe that he genuinely got some part of his body to the ball.

…regardless…

What does the scoreboard say!

Watched the replay and the goal umpire says it touched his right arm.

Exactly right. Do I know if it was touched or not myself? I have no flowering idea. I was a mile away. All these nuffies both opposition and media were at best 100s of metres away. The only bloke 3 metres away with a perfect view and who gets paid to made these calls said it was touched. End of story.

tommi · **Posted:** Mon Aug 14, 2023 12:06 pm

WHO cares hey….

that sort of talk by the…”narrative”…will only
galvanise the team…!

imagine THAT…the Blue boys becoming an even better
team…!

just give us the pup…!

kindest regards tommi

CK95 · **Posted:** Mon Aug 14, 2023 12:10 pm

missnaut wrote:

I've watched the replay, and the last two minutes several times and I still get horribly nervous.

I watched Q4 last night & yep, same here

tommi · **Posted:** Mon Aug 14, 2023 12:23 pm

Yup ^^^….

weird hey….!

if Ed got that kick to Charlie better at the end
there…or TDK took the mark 15 meters out…?

we wouldn’t be talking about the touch…!

kindest regards tommi

CK95 · **Posted:** Mon Aug 14, 2023 12:28 pm

So many 'almost' moments.....!

Menzel_Mayhem · **Joined:** Sun Aug 25, 2013 11:44 am **Posts:** 836

I haven’t heard us roar that loudly since Judd kicked a goal in the 3rd against Richmond in 2013 final. Watching the replay gives me chills. The siren sounds and the lid is OFF!

R22: Carlton v Melbourne (Post match Discussion)

Who is online