There is no thuggery in either incident. Just putting the hurt on. How is this any worse than a full forward steaming out and copping some hapless defender in the face or a brick outhouse follower smashing a smaller follower?

Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk

Young started to bend down toward the ball and when he realised Zurhaar would beat him to it, he just stopped and pulled out of the contest.
What do they want him to do? Blink his eyes and disappear?

_________________
Looking forward to seeing our potential realised.

Anyone have a link to footage of the bumps?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

_________________

I hope the club challenges the Young decision. Stocker shouldn’t be rubbed out either but I can almost accept it because he did make the decision to bump rather than tackle. Young did not have that choice.

_________________
It's never as good as it looks and it's never as bad as it seems.

Loved both bumps. Reckon most footy fans would agree.
It’s what we’ve been missing. Both incidents were hard but fair.
Morphing into basketball more by the day.

_________________
I just want my old club back ... (edit) maybe I have!

I feel the same way.
Stocker did decide to bump and as it turned out came off second best.
The Young one is a joke.

I think stocker is going to miss thru injury anyway right?

The Young one is just a deadset joke.

That said, great intent from our players and for the first time in bloody ages we physically intimidated a team.

Worthy investment.

_________________
Congratulations CK95

I'm sure I've read you say you were a fan....

_________________
#DonTheStash

The Young One should easily be downgraded. Classified as high impact. If the North player came back on and played out the game its medium impact and a fine.

Should have been a free paid against Eleni for blocking a player going for the ball.

Stocker out due to injury and suspension and Williams in
LOB out and Hewitt in with Walsh to run the wing.
If Young is out due to suspension then Parks in.

But if you kick someone.....

Exactly.

Esp Young who I wasn't sure was a tough player. Good to see him play strong.

Young ought not be penalised because Zuhart talks tough but doesn't back it up. Whinged like a bitch when he hobbled off

Adel game will be like the Norf game. We will be expected to win so need to make sure we do. All about the team maturing.

LOB out? Are you serious? Gets dropped before Cottrell &/or Newnes?

Hope we appeal the Young suspension.
I reckon he has gone past Oscar.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Sam Edmund
@Sammy__Edmund
·
9m
Carlton IS set to appeal the Lewis Young one-match ban for forceful front-on contact on Cam Zurhaar. Was assessed as careless, high impact, body contact. The Blues won't appeal the Liam Stocker suspension. More coming on @WhateleySEN

_________________
"You are being watched. The government has a secret system. A machine that spies on you every hour of every day. I know because I built it." - Finch

I didn't really count Cottrell in as he was the sub, so Cottrell out and LOB sub then.
I still think Newnes game was better then LOBs on the weekend. LOB was great as usual when he's 10m clear on the outside.

LOB was actually amazing on the weekend. Best game I have seem him play in a long long time. No way he gets dropped. Did you see his kicking into our forward line? Going to be a hard one. Who to drop. Stocker out so if williams is ready he replaces him. Hewitt replaces anyone in my book. Candidates - Newnes, Plowman. Cottrel doesnt count, but if we drop Plowman he can be the sub. I think Newnes had his best game for a while too.