Synbad wrote:
dannyboy wrote:
yes but with today's diet would he be 188cm? With his body being fed better food form birht he might be gee 195 or 198cm...who the F@%&#! knows? Not you not Ashman and Not barass. What they are talking about is him then versus players now - a silly comparison.
What i would say is this, all this equal, Nick would play in any era.
comparing anything from a past era to today is ridiculous.. that was my point all along... re 93 shithouse team playing in a GF.. (that we didnt win)... maybe Athorn playing today would have been a shit hot player.. with diets and stuff. he may have been 195cms and fast like Judd .. with perfect ball skills... and Scholl.. would have been our Barry Hall .... you know? with how they feed people these days.. all that genetically modified stuff....
So any chance we go for Father Sons here. Athorn Jnr to be the equal of Pavlich and Scholl Jnr something like Gherig.... After all these Jrs would be on these diets today, thats how they feed them these days.
Are they eligble ?? Prob not.
