ColourMan wrote:
GWS wrote:
ColourMan wrote:
No argument about the improvement, however that improvement is nowhere near where it should be... the great forest has far too many bare patches.
Which list manager/recruiters do you think have a better record over the last four years?
For starters, he’s been in charge for five years not four years... that’s five trade trade periods, five drafts... there won’t be too many clubs, if any, that had the selections that we had at the pointy end of the draft... and I doubt there’s any club that has done worse than us at the back end of the draft (including the rookie draft).
We’ve found a way to do less with more, while other clubs have done more with less...
When you look at what he’s done in detail (as well as what he hasn’t done), then it’s obvious why he’s being moved on... most here aren’t interested or care about the detail.
Absolute rubbish from any point of view. The only problem has been the rookie draft. No data to support this view yet at all.
If Gibbons comes good then that even takes care of the Rookies...
But keep spinning that tale.
Pinch of salt with all these posts. They’re not exactly a exactly full of reasoning or detail, just broad strokes of opinion masked as knowledge.
We had the worst list since Fitzroy... but we should have won a premiership already I guess.
This is a funny post... there’s been a stack of detail provided during this time, most people here haven’t been interested in the details... finally, people at the club are, it’s why he’s leaving...