If Jamison, Murphy, Judd, Yarran and Menzel are fit:

Out: Jones, Walker, Carrazzo, Tutt, White
In: Kreuzer, Boekhorst, Judd, Murphy, Jamison

_________________
29 different attributes,
And only 7 that you like;
20 ways to see the world,
Or 20 ways to start a fight.

Problem with Whiley so far, he's just so slow. So of thought, slow of action. I guess the only way to see if he's going to make it long term is to give him an extended run to see if it's something he'll overcome with comfort/exposure. But in doing so you're effectively going in one down. Not promising.

Menz knee might be ok. Was apparently jumping over chairs @ box hill yesterday.

haha

yeah, carrots was a real match winner.

Buckley has 2 elements worth everything to our forward line now. They are energy and hardness. Play him there for 3 weeks, he will rub off on those around him

fair enough. id actually wouldn't mind seeing thouy abit further up the ground because of two factors ... one he can kick a long goal which will put the opponents at odd i.e. they will either run towards Thouy making it easier for him to pass to a forward in a better position, or let him have a crack and he is great on the run 50+ out ...

its a win win for us.

I know he is injured but could you slot the other irish lad (Byrne?) who showed abit into defence to allow thouy/yarren to roam forward abit more ...

anyways ... yeah, lets get a really solid set up down back ... getting the no.1 pick this year looks like a fair chance for us, and all reports is the no 1 player is a seriously CHB player as well so him with Hendo with Jaksch upforward perhaps could work ...

_________________
Got to love the stare Down by Setanta on Llyod

You wanted Whiley in ahead of him, who mentioned him being a "match winner"??

FB: Tuohy Jamison White
HB: Simpson Rowe Docherty
C: Everitt Cripps Thomas
HF: Boekhorst Henderson Menzel
F: Buckley Casboult Jaksch
R: Wood Judd Bell
Int: Graham Armfield Carrazzo Curnow

In: Jaksch Boekhorst Jamison Judd
Out: Yarran Jones Walker Tutt

_________________
dane's trolling again

nah, not me. i don't want whiley anywhere near the first team.

i'd take carrots ahead of whiley everyday. carrots at least talks out on the field.

B: Tuohy Rowe White/Jammo
HB: Docherty Henderson Simpson

Foll: Wood/Kreuzer Judd Murphy
C: Curnow Cripps Yarran

HF: Menzel Casboult Bell
F: Everitt Jaksch Buckley

Int: Graham Whiley Thomas Boekhurst

Seems there's good chance Menzel and Yarran are going to be ok. Walker needs time to regain fitness in the NBs.

Only one of the two rucks. Casboult plays hs best when he gets his hands on the ball early in the ruck. Seems to help his confidence hence his game, both in the ruck and up forward. Confidence tends to disintegrate when he only stuck up forward.

I also believe Jaksch should become a fwd but don't believe he should come in now without playing as a fwd at VFL for awhile.

Tuohy. Rowe. Yarran.
Docherty. Jamo. Hendo.
Simmo. Graham. Thomas.
Bucks. Casboult. Bell.
Everitt. Kreuzer. Armfield.
Wood. Cripps. Judd.
Boekhorst. Carazzo. Walks.
Sub: Holman.

In Kreuzer. Jamo. Judd. Boekhorst. Holman.
Out jones. White. Tutt. Menzel. Curnow.

Yep that's the criteria...talking on the field
Would you take Carrots ahead of that onfield orator Bruce Doull.?
Carrots is FINITO. If you need a large tumbler of water to help you digest that, be my guest
And to put a line through Whiley at this stage is nonsensical

_________________
If I want your opinion, I'll give it to you!

Backs: Rowe, Jamison, Simpson
HB: Docherty, Henderson, Touhy
Centre: Kreuzer, Murphy, Cripps, Bell, Walker, Yarran
HF: Jaksch, Everitt, Gibbs
FF: Army, Casboult, Buckley

Bench: Curnow, Judd, Menzel, Wood

Emergency: Thomas, White, Boekhurst

_________________
A Blues Supporter - not a Blues Bagger.

Thinking long term, I seriously doubt it's in Kreuzer's best interests to bring him back now. I'd like to see him have at least one more hit out in the VFL and, depending how he pulls up, bring him back after the Bye.

_________________
It's never as good as it looks and it's never as bad as it seems.

I really want us to win this one.
Help Screw up their finals hopes.

The Jacobs Betts factor hurts.

Hope Kreuzer is included, same with Jammo Judd Menzel Murphy and Yarran.

jaksch should be doing his apprenticeship in the forward line

_________________
Everyone looks good in Navy Blue

Larkins says Yazz to miss two with ligament strain. Menz knee swelling being monitored.
Murph 50:50. Gibbs no.

Should get Jamo & Judd though. Hopefully Kreuz too.

You're absolutely right. No point whatever bringing him back this week.

You can therefore expect him to be named.

If they do it's a sign of panic.

If they don't it maybe they have learned something.

Sorry @#$%&! all chance we will even get close.

Is it wrong that I only want to go to this game to see Eddie Betts play?

_________________
#DonTheStash

No.

_________________
"our electorate seeks less to be informed and more to be validated." Sad times.