Navy Blue Horse wrote:
bondiblue wrote:
That's what I just heard on the commentary watching the Swans game.
I thought he was our best player till he got injured.
With Richmond Essendon*** and Port ahead and. 2 games out, I can see NM and Adel going past us...and Brisbane was in contention too.
We've fallen away this year without the injury levels of 2012 and that proves the list was done.
last year we missed Jammo Waite and Henderson in our spine. Today we got smashed by kids growing.
I do question MM because the list is better than last year other than the fact Judd carried the team last year.
Judd carried the team today when we had the rotations happening. Judd got injured and the house of cards collapsed.
Where do we go post Judd. I reckon our seasons done.
The reason for the thread is that it's a serious issue for Carltonians
How is the list better?
The point I was making is that for those who believe that injury robbed Ratten of success, this year we cant use that excuse asand its the same list and we should be better. yeah?... And whether we are in trouble with or without Juddy
I like to factor 'wear' and 'tear' and 'age' going against us.
When we look at our best, our best fit into the 3 categories, and it's grim.
I don't think we can do better than we did today without Judd.
Can of worms...it's all here in TC.....it was predicted.....not by me....rose coloured glasses and I'm
a lot going through me head...threads and threads worth.
I'm on Synbad's side. have been for years, but Rose Coloured Glasses....I still believe and want to slap myself.
Big deal...it's only footy.