Although a few notables went from "when MM get's here" to "if MM get's the job" for about 4 weeks.

They're back on the "when" wagon now though. So I'll give them that.

I made a "credibility note" a short while ago that a couple of posters, pretty sure Synners was one of them knew a few weeks previous, for a FACT, that a) Ratten was gone and b) Malthouse had the gig.

They're at least half right.

(Synners cops a lot of flak, some of it from me, but I reckon credit where it's due).

Although a few notables went from "when MM get's here" to "if MM get's the job" for about 4 weeks.

They're back on the "when" wagon now though. So I'll give them that.

ok, well on here at the moment two people are claiming the following:

Person 1. MM will start in two weeks
Person 2. MM will start on Oct 1

I'm sure whoever is wrong will have an excuse. Like me saying:

Carlton will recruit a big name in the off season, I can't say who but my source is the same person that told me we were getting Judd before he even said he was leaving the Eagles.

good chance that I'll be correct, if I'm not it'll be quickly forgotten. Unless it's Friday related.

I still dont see it. Can someone set me straight?
We have a 59 year old man who coached for 16 consecutive years without a premiership at the 2 best resourced clubs in the AFL.
He was a balls bounce away from defeat in the 2010 GF by a team that has half the talent of Collingwood IMO.

Well BV if you are going to use that as logic for what you don't see perhaps you forgot about the 2002 grandfinal when with a team with quarter of the talent not half of Brisbane he nearly got them over the line. Take away Voss's last 15 minutes in that game and the cup was the Pies. If you want me to open your eyes even further the poor old bastard had his team peaking and playing in Grand Finals against two teams that happen to win 3 flags each in their period of dominance.
I just hope I don't have to sit through another home and away game against Hawthorn when after the first 5 min utes I know the game is over, year after year after year, or we play a team who decides to limit our run and spread and choke the friggin life out of us.

Well BV if you are going to use that as logic for what you don't see perhaps you forgot about the 2002 grandfinal when with a team with quarter of the talent not half of Brisbane he nearly got them over the line. Take away Voss's last 15 minutes in that game and the cup was the Pies. If you want me to open your eyes even further the poor old bastard had his team peaking and playing in Grand Finals against two teams that happen to win 3 flags each in their period of dominance.
I just hope I don't have to sit through another home and away game against Hawthorn when after the first 5 minutes I know the game is over, year after year after year, or we play a team who decides to limit our run and spread and choke the friggin life out of us.

Its about premierships. Being runners up means jack shit.
Celebrating coming second or third is for St Kilda.
The history books tell us Malthouse has won 1 premiership in his last 17 years of trying. He's past it.