Tommy Alvin wrote:
I think this is a really important point. Other than Judd, we have no seasoned professionals who have knowledge of what it takes to succeed week in, week out, season after season. I have enormous respect for Simpson, and a lot of time for Scotland, but these guys are not leaders. They are guys that have worked very hard to be good contributors. Role models in terms of workrate, yes, but they make too many errors for them to be the guys that our young kids look up to or the guys that we turn to when we need to show some spine, hit some bodies and stop the hurt on the scoreboard.
For example, in the forwardline, we are crying out for somebody who has the authority to tell people where to run, who to block (has anyone seen a block laid in the forwardline this year?), when to kick for goal rather than attempt a difficult pass.
But the reality is that the lack of leadership on the field, whilst a massive problem, is very difficult to solve in a matter of weeks - the hope is that the coaching staff can fill the void until the list matures (see Hardwick coaching from the boundary line - all about morale, confidence, team psychology) but the fact is, since the Hawthorn game, we have played one impressive quarter of football (1st quarter vs Melbourne) - that's a seriously long trough of poor form - and I'm not hearing the sounds from anyone at the club that this is unacceptable, that we demand more in terms of effort and output. Not from Judd, not from Ratts, not from anyone. Lacklustre wins over WCE and Brisbane have allowed the club to avoid being pilloried until now, when it is almost too late. Now, only when the media scrutiny really kicks into action, may we start to get a response. That's not leadership, that's being led a merry flowering dance.
Ratts sat at today's press conference and effectively said to the media - 'well you guys didn't think we'd make the 8 at all! So lay off!' - stuck his chin out and tried to act like nothing is wrong. I've always liked Ratts, but whereas other clubs would have drawn a line in the sand, or signed a footy before the game and committed to making 100% effort, absolutely refusing to accept anything other than a big, fat W - we talk about predictions that were made months ago by outsiders.
We lack leadership on the field, yes, but it's symptomatic of a rudderless ship of a footy club at the moment.
[Insert Kennedy's 'don't think, do' half-time speech]
I'd be printing out a copy of the ladder, giving it to each player tomorrow and emphasising that this season is still well and truly alive, but that the time has come to lift, collectively, and work for each other.
Ok, end of rant.
Intelligent, considered rant Tommy.
