Why Silvagni WAS great for us

doofdoof · **Joined:** Mon Aug 20, 2007 1:54 pm **Posts:** 2251

so now you're using the before SOS era to strengthen your bagging of SOS?

good one

ColourMan · **Joined:** Sun Dec 23, 2007 11:51 am **Posts:** 1291

doofdoof wrote:

so now you're using the before SOS era to strengthen your bagging of SOS?

good one

Yep that's exactly what I was doing which is why i clearly pointed out the rookies on Richmond's list prior to SOS's timeframe.... how late picks/rookies can transform a club... yet SOS ignored those picks because he was lazy and not very good... now I'm bagging SOS..

8 players compared to 1... facts that tells you everything you need to know...

The board moving SOS on (with his best friend and mates on the board) tells you everything you need to know (I'll give you a hint, they don't think he did a very good job... they were seriously bagging SOS)...

Yet you still don't know

doofdoof · **Joined:** Mon Aug 20, 2007 1:54 pm **Posts:** 2251

I’ll give you a hint...I know how you feel about SOS. It’s only in all of your posts. No need to throw in bullshit about club politics you claim to know to support it

Meanwhile, I think he did a good job overall. We’ll all know how good over the next few years as some of our young guys develop further. For now, let’s leave it at that

AGRO · **Posted:** Wed Dec 18, 2019 10:13 pm

doofdoof wrote:

I’ll give you a hint...I know how you feel about SOS. It’s only in all of your posts. No need to throw in bullshit about club politics you claim to know to support it

Meanwhile, I think he did a good job overall. We’ll all know how good over the next few years as some of our young guys develop further. For now, let’s leave it at that

I’ll give you a hint since you can’t afford to buy a clue.

He’s not bullshitting.

doofdoof · **Joined:** Mon Aug 20, 2007 1:54 pm **Posts:** 2251

Good for him

murraycray · **Posted:** Thu Dec 19, 2019 5:25 am

What I find odd is the club found it necessary to move Stephen Silvagni on without having a replacement potentially ready to go. ''Apparently'' Kinnear Beatson has knocked them back, which is not surprising really.
He has a good gig in Sydney !

So where or who to now ?

Agresta may be a fall back option ? If that were to happen it would be because the club has bombed out elsewhere, and he'd get the job by default.
Lots to play out here, particularly when you think this really didn't need to happen right now.

camel · **Posted:** Thu Dec 19, 2019 9:14 am

The question was asked a while back if Jack and Ben would have been recruited if they weren't Silvagnis?

I wonder, would SOS have been given his recruiting gig if he wasn't a Silvagni?

Blue Sombrero · **Posted:** Thu Dec 19, 2019 2:08 pm

As the pages roll by and the thread get longer, the vitriol gets more bitter. The ITKs spill their bile and the lemmings nod wisely.
At Richmond the supporters always threaten to burn their membership cards. At Carlton we prefer to eat our own. Always have.
So many successful eras have been cut short or hijacked by politicking and blood letting behind closed doors.
Jezza, Walls, Percy, Brittain and Ratts to name a few that were pushed out before their time through politics and or the Messiah coach complex.
It's not surprising it flows down to the supporters.

People calling for a united club in one breath slag off at the board, the players, the coach and the committee the next.
That's what being a real Carlton person is all about.

AGRO · **Posted:** Thu Dec 19, 2019 2:18 pm

doofdoof wrote:

Good for him

You should get a week off for that.

But I bet you won’t.

:wink:

camel · **Posted:** Thu Dec 19, 2019 2:19 pm

You should move on.

But I know you won't.

Sydney Blue · **Posted:** Thu Dec 19, 2019 3:37 pm

Surely if they are looking to replace SOS then Keogh would be their number 1 target

Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk

AGRO · **Posted:** Thu Dec 19, 2019 3:56 pm

camelboy wrote:

You should move on.

But I know you won't.

The board has established that the term “good for you” doesn’t actually mean “good for you”.

Just wanting to ensure that consistency and fairness prevails.

billc3 · **Joined:** Mon Feb 28, 2005 2:41 pm **Posts:** 4548

murraycray wrote:

What I find odd is the club found it necessary to move Stephen Silvagni on without having a replacement potentially ready to go. ''Apparently'' Kinnear Beatson has knocked them back, which is not surprising really.
He has a good gig in Sydney !

So where or who to now ?

Agresta may be a fall back option ? If that were to happen it would be because the club has bombed out elsewhere, and he'd get the job by default.
Lots to play out here, particularly when you think this really didn't need to happen right now.

Aren't they after someone from Freo?

Can't see that Freo has been a shinning light in recruitment, but maybe the role is different

Go Blues

keogh · **Joined:** Fri Jul 29, 2005 6:36 am **Posts:** 5984

Sydney Blue wrote:

Surely if they are looking to replace SOS then Keogh would be their number 1 target

Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk

Sos’s Legacy will be there for all to see in 3 years
Based on Mc Govern, Setterfields output is
Plus others
The output of Dow and others
His inability to recruit talent with late picks and rookie picks
is without question
Some posters say he is or was great
That’s the favoured son can’t do no wrong syndrome

It’s a bit like a loyal royalist saying that Prince Andrew isn’t a peddy

dannyboy · **Posted:** Fri Dec 20, 2019 7:30 am

a bit like....drawn any longer that bow would catch on the rings of Saturn.

Steve_C7 · **Joined:** Tue Mar 27, 2007 1:39 pm **Posts:** 1002

keogh wrote:

Sydney Blue wrote:

Surely if they are looking to replace SOS then Keogh would be their number 1 target

Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk

Sos’s Legacy will be there for all to see in 3 years
Based on Mc Govern, Setterfields output is
Plus others
The output of Dow and others
His inability to recruit talent with late picks and rookie picks
is without question
Some posters say he is or was great
That’s the favoured son can’t do no wrong syndrome

It’s a bit like a loyal royalist saying that Prince Andrew isn’t a peddy

So everyone else has to wait 3 years to judge SOS's legacy, however you are free to call it now :confused:

Blue Boys · **Joined:** Sun Feb 17, 2008 10:35 pm **Posts:** 1233

keogh wrote:

Sydney Blue wrote:

Surely if they are looking to replace SOS then Keogh would be their number 1 target

Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk

Sos’s Legacy will be there for all to see in 3 years
Based on Mc Govern, Setterfields output is
Plus others
The output of Dow and others
His inability to recruit talent with late picks and rookie picks
is without question
Some posters say he is or was great
That’s the favoured son can’t do no wrong syndrome

It’s a bit like a loyal royalist saying that Prince Andrew isn’t a peddy

I'm not sure many will care about those late draft picks when we win number 18 within the next few years!

blues_clues · **Joined:** Mon Aug 19, 2019 4:31 pm **Posts:** 35

GWS had some interest in Jack Silvagni.......

Trigger · **Joined:** Fri Sep 21, 2012 11:06 am **Posts:** 1826

blues_clues wrote:

GWS had some interest in Jack Silvagni.......

Hopefully he goes, not a great loss!!

GWS · **Posted:** Fri Dec 20, 2019 6:44 pm

blues_clues wrote:

GWS had some interest in Jack Silvagni.......

I lost it when he started tweeting...

Why Silvagni WAS great for us

Who is online