JohnM wrote:
Sinners, I know you only want what's best for the club, but I really think we can only accurately assess our coaching after the halfway point of this season.
By Swann's own admission, Ratten has coached this club for two AFL games. Swann has said that he doesn't count last season when assessing Ratten (make of that what you will, but I think the inference is pretty clear).
Ratts may or may not make it, we can't possibly know yet. That's why he was given 2 years, not 3. But what I'm looking for is signs of improvement in the TEAM (not individuals) in the second half of the season.
Until then, I think it's premature to be planting the Ratts out/Worsfold in seed.
The bigger issue for me is whether or not our entire coaching and development set-up is good enough yet. Are we planning to replicate or better the Port Adelaide 'academy'? Or Collingwood's successful development? Do the Bullants work well enough? Can playing coaches really work? And, yes, does Ratts have the attributes?
Way too early to be pointing the finger at Ratts, in my opinion.
Although, having said that, I wouldn't mind seeing Mark Williams at Princes Park

finally, someone with some common sense.
its got me stuffed why Ratten is given such shit after two games.
we played a fully fit Richmond, and a near fully fit St Kilda.
for patches of both games, we had them on the run ... it seems commen sense to me, that the initial parts of our game, we do them well and that is what we should be implementing for 4 quarters.
currently we cant do that, and that is why we have lost two games.
im pretty confident we are heading in the right direction, we need to increase our fitness levels, but when we play they way i think we can we are as good if not better than any of the sides we have played to date and several more that we havent.
we are a side that needs time, and we are still young.
forget what other mugs say, our starting 22 would be younger, by miles than any other side in the comp.
but back onto ratten
Just as Knights isnt the saviour of Essendon* after 1 win, nor is Ratten useless after 2 loses.
Hell, to me, it seems the only ones that make an issue about Ratten is Carlton people.
_________________
Got to love the stare Down by Setanta on Llyod
