mjonc wrote:
Trade Fev and use Harts and JFK rotating between the key posts with Waite and Fisher as flankers and the problem is solved.
I think Fev has more value than the high draft pick that you would get for him. I also think he has more value than the first round pick and second/third season player that you would get if he cleaned up his act before the end of the season. I also think he has more value to our team than Judd would bring to a team without Fev (for those who are naiive enough to think that
might happen).
The set up was good when we went tall against Freo. The supply wasn't. Our midfield either didn't work hard enough or they didn't work smart enough when we had the ball. Every time someone did something good to win the footy, the support in extracting the ball with run wasn't there. Inevitably, the disposal would lack quality because there was either too much pressure or the decision was rushed.
I can see JFK fitting into that structure as opposed to Carlos whose value as a defender outweighs his forward skills at the moment. What Carlos lacks in set-shot kicking mechanics is something that needs to be addressed away from the game time. What he has in hunger and passion for a contest is something that we desperately need accross half back.
The beauty here is that they both have enough rucking ability to provide relief during a game for a young tap ruckman who is not quite strong enough to handle the rigours of a full game in the ruck.
I see a future without Ackland and Saddington and perhaps that's where we need to be at the moment. Put it on all these kids with some ruck abilities to make their name as a key defensive player because that is where they will get a game in the next week or so.
I would also put it on our nine best runners to justify their place on the field. They need to know each other's stregths and weaknesses and find a way to work together. They need to communicate on tactics amongst each other rather than waiting to be told. If they want to know what it feels like to control the tempo then they need to grow up enough to fix a situation themselves before it becomes a five goal problem.