Big Kahuna Boot wrote:
Virgin Blue wrote:
You obviously missed the bit where I said 'But in saying that, I don't think we can judge him for another 2 years'
And you're comment about off-loadin Fev is mere spin. Had we not got a young KPP in the deal (Hendo) the faithful would have torn down the remaining grand stands at VISY Park. Hendo was part of the big deal, so don't delude yourself into thinking we got him for free.
206 was Picks 24, 56 and 72. Pick 24 is not insignificant, and give our luck with some latish picks over the journey, I'm guessing giving up 3 picks for a player was not something the club did lightly.
Hey, we're all hopeful and optimistic and positive etc, but reality is 206 and Brock have a bit to prove.
..heh, yeah i did miss that part..
..not sure how my comment regarding fev is 'spin'.. ..you don't think we were gonna off-load him regardless..?.. ..who knows what we would have taken in a deal just to facilitate one.. ..Hendo rightfully so saw his KPF chances diminish greatly with the brions chasin' fev hard, and saw his golden opportunity open up with us.. ..as for the carlton faithful, the real faithful understood fev Had to go.. ..i'm not sayin' we got him for free, but we were lucky to get him in the circumstances, cos we were sellin' fev at below market value, and everyone knew it..
I don't think they would have got rid of him for nothing. It's not just about us, but also about making other teams stronger. You don't allow Fev/Brown to team up in a Voss Wet Dream Fwdline for nuthin.
I do see Hendo as a gift, bec I think in time he will mature into a good fwd for us. He is not overly quick, and he needs a couple more years before he can hold those tight marks on the lead, but he has a good head on his shoulders, and seems competent enough from what I have seen. So I expect over time he will become a good KPP.
But I personally don't think we'd have got rid of Fev for nuthin, and so personally I think Hendo partly cost us 80-100 gls this year. Now I don't expect him to re-pay us in 2010, let alone 2011. But in 2012 and beyond if he doesn't start to really re-pay us, then I will be saying loud and clear we didn't get value for the 80-100 gls a year we lost in Fevola. Of course Fevola could go on and do something unbelievably stupid in the next couple years and get sacked by the Lions, and so Hendo would be a gift if that happened I spose.
