frank dardew wrote:
No you are the one running the agenda and will not recognise the present deficiencies in his performance and what matters he should be accountable or responsible for
The rest of us think at 4-12 he isn’t performing if you are happy with that and think he is going well then I suspect you are in the category of 5 percent of Carlton members and supporters but you are rtiyled to that view
However contrary To your view if he was going as well as you say he is then why is the club having an external review of the football department half way through the season
Doesn’t that even suggest to you that the board and CEO to have such a review not at the end of the season as is normal but halfway through the season thinks there has being gross underperformance and when we are 14 th of an 18 team competition is that an acceptable performance with our list even taking into account injuries
Once again it is not his fault solely but surely he is responsible and accountable for the issues I raised in the previous post
H, Weitering on track to win AA
Rookies like Parks, Owies performing above expectations
Walsh on track for B&F
Jones solid
Stocker has shown AFL qualities on few occassions
Dow hasnt changed his ways since his debut and should be reprogrammed in VFL.
Fisher has been injured and been playing on and off past year so has Martin
Williams not coping but better past couple of games - Leaders in Docherty and Cripps need to pull the finger out and play elite football unconditionally as club leaders.
Charlie and Marchbank have been missing.. TDK has had injury problems...Newman has had injury problems....Plowman could do better as a senior player.
Kennedy hopefully improves but dont see it coming - hope I'm wrong. Setterfield needs to pull his finger out sent to VFL to find his tackling form again and now injured again.
I am realistic that we are playing football to expectation - not going to beat top sides with key players out and they have a full list to choose from.
What else is there other than sound bites?