TalkingCarlton
https://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/

R12: Carlton v West Coast (Pre Match Discussion)
https://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=37220
Page 5 of 10

Author:  CK95 [ Fri Jun 04, 2021 2:04 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: R12: Carlton v West Coast (Pre Match Discussion)

jim wrote:
Let's hope we can bring the pressure tomorrow.

Just watched a game against Hawthorn in 1995. Comparing it to now, in every aspect, was like comparing chalk and cheese. So well drilled and understood every move of their teammates. Never seen pressure, hardness, skill like it and still don't see it in the current era from any side. Forgot what it was like. Hawthorn were physically and mentally shattered mess by the last qtr. I've never been big on ruck stuff but watching Madden I forgot what the craft was like. Won near every tap, tapped with authority, knew where he was tapping, and the Carlton mids, knew where it was coming, read it so well and jumped on it like a seagull on a hot chip. His tap work made Nic Nat to his mids look like an amateur. There was barely one out of the centre didn't go to advantage. Must've been 90% to advantage out of the centre.

Where did it all go? Admittedly that was one of the great individual sides of all time but still, we are the opposite that side in every respect. It's a reminder of what we need to bring if we are ever going to rise right up the ladder again.



Do yourself a favour & watch the first qtr of us & Geelong at PP the same year, one of the best quarters of footy you'll ever see. Both teams.

Author:  Blue4ever [ Fri Jun 04, 2021 2:24 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: R12: Carlton v West Coast (Pre Match Discussion)

CK95 wrote:
jim wrote:
Let's hope we can bring the pressure tomorrow.

Just watched a game against Hawthorn in 1995. Comparing it to now, in every aspect, was like comparing chalk and cheese. So well drilled and understood every move of their teammates. Never seen pressure, hardness, skill like it and still don't see it in the current era from any side. Forgot what it was like. Hawthorn were physically and mentally shattered mess by the last qtr. I've never been big on ruck stuff but watching Madden I forgot what the craft was like. Won near every tap, tapped with authority, knew where he was tapping, and the Carlton mids, knew where it was coming, read it so well and jumped on it like a seagull on a hot chip. His tap work made Nic Nat to his mids look like an amateur. There was barely one out of the centre didn't go to advantage. Must've been 90% to advantage out of the centre.

Where did it all go? Admittedly that was one of the great individual sides of all time but still, we are the opposite that side in every respect. It's a reminder of what we need to bring if we are ever going to rise right up the ladder again.



Do yourself a favour & watch the first qtr of us & Geelong at PP the same year, one of the best quarters of footy you'll ever see. Both teams.


Oh the good old days, took it for granted.

Author:  AGRO [ Fri Jun 04, 2021 3:02 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: R12: Carlton v West Coast (Pre Match Discussion)

CK95 wrote:
jim wrote:
Let's hope we can bring the pressure tomorrow.

Just watched a game against Hawthorn in 1995. Comparing it to now, in every aspect, was like comparing chalk and cheese. So well drilled and understood every move of their teammates. Never seen pressure, hardness, skill like it and still don't see it in the current era from any side. Forgot what it was like. Hawthorn were physically and mentally shattered mess by the last qtr. I've never been big on ruck stuff but watching Madden I forgot what the craft was like. Won near every tap, tapped with authority, knew where he was tapping, and the Carlton mids, knew where it was coming, read it so well and jumped on it like a seagull on a hot chip. His tap work made Nic Nat to his mids look like an amateur. There was barely one out of the centre didn't go to advantage. Must've been 90% to advantage out of the centre.

Where did it all go? Admittedly that was one of the great individual sides of all time but still, we are the opposite that side in every respect. It's a reminder of what we need to bring if we are ever going to rise right up the ladder again.





Do yourself a favour & watch the first qtr of us & Geelong at PP the same year, one of the best quarters of footy you'll ever see. Both teams.




Probably the best and most exhilarating game of football I’ve ever seen at Princes Park.

:thumbsup:


Although I would have liked to have been at the Carlton -v- Geelong game 23rd June 1990 when we came back from 48 points down to win - but had another more pressing engagement that day - the birth of my beautiful daughter.

:lol:

Author:  Blue Vain [ Fri Jun 04, 2021 3:16 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: R12: Carlton v West Coast (Pre Match Discussion)

Crusader wrote:
jamespul65 wrote:
on sen saying that we are playing wce reserves side/ must win by 5 goals to shut everyone up or if we lose media trucks will be a PP monday

Better chance for a quote if they roll up to Sydney.

Just saying...



:lol:

Author:  AGRO [ Fri Jun 04, 2021 3:39 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: R12: Carlton v West Coast (Pre Match Discussion)

Unless I miss my guess we are going to get schooled in how a serious AFL team performs with their replacement players performing their roles.


:thumbsup:

Author:  Teddy Hopkins [ Fri Jun 04, 2021 4:03 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: R12: Carlton v West Coast (Pre Match Discussion)

Effes wrote:
Cottrell DE was 30% last week.

How does he maintain his spot?

Maybe as a young player he is given a block of games to show his wares. Now if the MC was consistent I could live with that.

But he has been given his chance so back to the VFL to find form.

So how about Dow who was showing something before being dropped under the guise of injury, Parks, and Honey at the least be given the same opportunity.

Author:  17th Premiership [ Fri Jun 04, 2021 4:55 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: R12: Carlton v West Coast (Pre Match Discussion)

jamespul65 wrote:
on sen saying that we are playing wce reserves side/ must win by 5 goals to shut everyone up or if we lose media trucks will be a PP monday


Good! Whilst it is annoying that the media consistently ignores our injury issues and keeps giving them to our opposition, it is good for us to be put under pressure and to be doubted by the media/public.
We haven't exactly done a lot to engender trust and respect from the footy world. We need to earn that. Melbourne is only now just starting to begin to somewhat earn it after losing only one match by just one point... we have a lot of work to do to earn it.

It took the Geelong handbags a premiership before they began to be taken seriously. And let's not get started on the Colliwobbles, or Ninthmond!

We are playing an undermanned West Coast side. We should beat them, even with our undermanned team. And I'm fine with the heat being applied. Bring it on!

Author:  Effes [ Fri Jun 04, 2021 5:06 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: R12: Carlton v West Coast (Pre Match Discussion)

OUT: L Fogarty (managed), Gibbons (inj), Casboult
IN: P Dow, Z Fisher

Author:  jake_h03 [ Fri Jun 04, 2021 5:08 pm ]
Post subject:  R12: Carlton v West Coast (Pre Match Discussion)

Fish and Dow in

Levi Gibbons Fogarty out

Happy with those changes. Thank @#$%&! the TDK Levi Pitto disaster has been aborted. Would much prefer SPS on the wing over Cottrell, but this MC is never going to get them all right. This week is better than most


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

Author:  Navy Blue Horse [ Fri Jun 04, 2021 5:09 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: R12: Carlton v West Coast (Pre Match Discussion)

Effes wrote:
OUT: L Fogarty (managed), Gibbons (inj), Casboult
IN: P Dow, Z Fisher



Murphy into the 22 also for those playing at home

Author:  Sidefx [ Fri Jun 04, 2021 5:09 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: R12: Carlton v West Coast (Pre Match Discussion)

jake_h03 wrote:
Fish and Dow in

Levi Gibbons Fogarty out

Happy with those changes. Thank @#$%&! the TDK Levi Pitto disaster has been aborted. Would much prefer SPS on the wing over Cottrell, but this MC is never going to get them all right. This week is better than most


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

:thumbsup:
I'm still not confident on a win.

Author:  grrofunger [ Fri Jun 04, 2021 5:15 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: R12: Carlton v West Coast (Pre Match Discussion)

Fogarty sub?

Author:  jim [ Fri Jun 04, 2021 5:19 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: R12: Carlton v West Coast (Pre Match Discussion)

AGRO wrote:
CK95 wrote:
jim wrote:
Let's hope we can bring the pressure tomorrow.

Just watched a game against Hawthorn in 1995. Comparing it to now, in every aspect, was like comparing chalk and cheese. So well drilled and understood every move of their teammates. Never seen pressure, hardness, skill like it and still don't see it in the current era from any side. Forgot what it was like. Hawthorn were physically and mentally shattered mess by the last qtr. I've never been big on ruck stuff but watching Madden I forgot what the craft was like. Won near every tap, tapped with authority, knew where he was tapping, and the Carlton mids, knew where it was coming, read it so well and jumped on it like a seagull on a hot chip. His tap work made Nic Nat to his mids look like an amateur. There was barely one out of the centre didn't go to advantage. Must've been 90% to advantage out of the centre.

Where did it all go? Admittedly that was one of the great individual sides of all time but still, we are the opposite that side in every respect. It's a reminder of what we need to bring if we are ever going to rise right up the ladder again.





Do yourself a favour & watch the first qtr of us & Geelong at PP the same year, one of the best quarters of footy you'll ever see. Both teams.




Probably the best and most exhilarating game of football I’ve ever seen at Princes Park.

:thumbsup:


Although I would have liked to have been at the Carlton -v- Geelong game 23rd June 1990 when we came back from 48 points down to win - but had another more pressing engagement that day - the birth of my beautiful daughter.

:lol:


i'm thinking that makes you pretty old now...lol.

Author:  jim [ Fri Jun 04, 2021 5:23 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: R12: Carlton v West Coast (Pre Match Discussion)

CK95 wrote:
jim wrote:
Let's hope we can bring the pressure tomorrow.

Just watched a game against Hawthorn in 1995. Comparing it to now, in every aspect, was like comparing chalk and cheese. So well drilled and understood every move of their teammates. Never seen pressure, hardness, skill like it and still don't see it in the current era from any side. Forgot what it was like. Hawthorn were physically and mentally shattered mess by the last qtr. I've never been big on ruck stuff but watching Madden I forgot what the craft was like. Won near every tap, tapped with authority, knew where he was tapping, and the Carlton mids, knew where it was coming, read it so well and jumped on it like a seagull on a hot chip. His tap work made Nic Nat to his mids look like an amateur. There was barely one out of the centre didn't go to advantage. Must've been 90% to advantage out of the centre.

Where did it all go? Admittedly that was one of the great individual sides of all time but still, we are the opposite that side in every respect. It's a reminder of what we need to bring if we are ever going to rise right up the ladder again.



Do yourself a favour & watch the first qtr of us & Geelong at PP the same year, one of the best quarters of footy you'll ever see. Both teams.


I remember that one. One of the really great examples of our game by both side.

Next time they played it was one of the great of examples of our game by one side. :grin:

Author:  jim [ Fri Jun 04, 2021 5:26 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: R12: Carlton v West Coast (Pre Match Discussion)

Official;

In: Dow, Fisher.

Our: Casboult (omitted), Gibbons (inj), Fogarty (managed).

Murphy is in just too after being 23rd man last week

Author:  bluebo baggers [ Fri Jun 04, 2021 5:26 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: R12: Carlton v West Coast (Pre Match Discussion)

jake_h03 wrote:
Fish and Dow in

Levi Gibbons Fogarty out

Happy with those changes. Thank @#$%&! the TDK Levi Pitto disaster has been aborted. Would much prefer SPS on the wing over Cottrell, but this MC is never going to get them all right. This week is better than most


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro


this.

Author:  CFC8795 [ Fri Jun 04, 2021 5:35 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: R12: Carlton v West Coast (Pre Match Discussion)

Another 'must win' game.
I have 'must win' fatigue. :smoking:
Losing doesn't help the situation :garthp:

Author:  CK95 [ Fri Jun 04, 2021 6:01 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: R12: Carlton v West Coast (Pre Match Discussion)

jim wrote:
CK95 wrote:
jim wrote:
Let's hope we can bring the pressure tomorrow.

Just watched a game against Hawthorn in 1995. Comparing it to now, in every aspect, was like comparing chalk and cheese. So well drilled and understood every move of their teammates. Never seen pressure, hardness, skill like it and still don't see it in the current era from any side. Forgot what it was like. Hawthorn were physically and mentally shattered mess by the last qtr. I've never been big on ruck stuff but watching Madden I forgot what the craft was like. Won near every tap, tapped with authority, knew where he was tapping, and the Carlton mids, knew where it was coming, read it so well and jumped on it like a seagull on a hot chip. His tap work made Nic Nat to his mids look like an amateur. There was barely one out of the centre didn't go to advantage. Must've been 90% to advantage out of the centre.

Where did it all go? Admittedly that was one of the great individual sides of all time but still, we are the opposite that side in every respect. It's a reminder of what we need to bring if we are ever going to rise right up the ladder again.



Do yourself a favour & watch the first qtr of us & Geelong at PP the same year, one of the best quarters of footy you'll ever see. Both teams.


I remember that one. One of the really great examples of our game by both side.

Next time they played it was one of the great of examples of our game by one side. :grin:
Haha well played.

They humiliated us in 1994...revenge was sweet!

Sent from my SM-A115F using Tapatalk

Author:  CK95 [ Fri Jun 04, 2021 6:04 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: R12: Carlton v West Coast (Pre Match Discussion)

AGRO wrote:
CK95 wrote:
jim wrote:
Let's hope we can bring the pressure tomorrow.

Just watched a game against Hawthorn in 1995. Comparing it to now, in every aspect, was like comparing chalk and cheese. So well drilled and understood every move of their teammates. Never seen pressure, hardness, skill like it and still don't see it in the current era from any side. Forgot what it was like. Hawthorn were physically and mentally shattered mess by the last qtr. I've never been big on ruck stuff but watching Madden I forgot what the craft was like. Won near every tap, tapped with authority, knew where he was tapping, and the Carlton mids, knew where it was coming, read it so well and jumped on it like a seagull on a hot chip. His tap work made Nic Nat to his mids look like an amateur. There was barely one out of the centre didn't go to advantage. Must've been 90% to advantage out of the centre.

Where did it all go? Admittedly that was one of the great individual sides of all time but still, we are the opposite that side in every respect. It's a reminder of what we need to bring if we are ever going to rise right up the ladder again.





Do yourself a favour & watch the first qtr of us & Geelong at PP the same year, one of the best quarters of footy you'll ever see. Both teams.




Probably the best and most exhilarating game of football I’ve ever seen at Princes Park.

:thumbsup:


Although I would have liked to have been at the Carlton -v- Geelong game 23rd June 1990 when we came back from 48 points down to win - but had another more pressing engagement that day - the birth of my beautiful daughter.

:lol:
41 points

48 was the Fev Essendon* game :)

Sent from my SM-A115F using Tapatalk

Author:  grrofunger [ Fri Jun 04, 2021 6:06 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: R12: Carlton v West Coast (Pre Match Discussion)

CK95 wrote:
AGRO wrote:
CK95 wrote:
jim wrote:
Let's hope we can bring the pressure tomorrow.

Just watched a game against Hawthorn in 1995. Comparing it to now, in every aspect, was like comparing chalk and cheese. So well drilled and understood every move of their teammates. Never seen pressure, hardness, skill like it and still don't see it in the current era from any side. Forgot what it was like. Hawthorn were physically and mentally shattered mess by the last qtr. I've never been big on ruck stuff but watching Madden I forgot what the craft was like. Won near every tap, tapped with authority, knew where he was tapping, and the Carlton mids, knew where it was coming, read it so well and jumped on it like a seagull on a hot chip. His tap work made Nic Nat to his mids look like an amateur. There was barely one out of the centre didn't go to advantage. Must've been 90% to advantage out of the centre.

Where did it all go? Admittedly that was one of the great individual sides of all time but still, we are the opposite that side in every respect. It's a reminder of what we need to bring if we are ever going to rise right up the ladder again.





Do yourself a favour & watch the first qtr of us & Geelong at PP the same year, one of the best quarters of footy you'll ever see. Both teams.




Probably the best and most exhilarating game of football I’ve ever seen at Princes Park.

:thumbsup:


Although I would have liked to have been at the Carlton -v- Geelong game 23rd June 1990 when we came back from 48 points down to win - but had another more pressing engagement that day - the birth of my beautiful daughter.

:lol:
41 points

48 was the Fev Essendon** game :)

Sent from my SM-A115F using Tapatalk


FEVOOOLLLLLAAAAAAA


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lk6kvVGPURA

Page 5 of 10 All times are UTC + 10 hours
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/