I choose not to be a member because deep down the board don’t give a @#$%&! about their members
The club is not transparent with its members
Unless the board [REDACTED] off or was booted off by another group which doesn’t look likely why should I be a member
The Carlton Footy Club has been part of my life as it has for all of us but I look at it differently now than 25 30 years ago
It’s been so badly run for so long that I won’t support the people on that board in any way shape or form
If you look at the out going President’s parting words in his report it’s full of outgoing lies and shit
Bondi Blue thought I was bad
As far as Cerra is concerned no
He is ok but Fremantle won’t trade him for one first round pick.
But he ain’t worth that anyway
Cerra is overrated by us. Once again the messiah approach
McGovern
Martin
Williams
Saad
Why does the club overrate him
In terms of stoppages he is ranked 6 th in his team
In contested possession he is ranked 6 th in his team
In terms of player ranking he is ranked 5 th for his team
In terms of tackles he isn’t in the top 100 in the league
He is 4 th in terms of possession in his team
He is clearly not a star
Brayshaw and Serong are better
He is a Kennedy standard mid
Once again this club and some posters are short sighted and look for the silver bullet
What amazes me is how the club and some supporters never @#$%&! look back and see how we have continually made the same mistakes
Now you want to give up a first round pick for a fifth string mid
Let me tell you guys again
This list isn’t good enough
Go to the draft get kids for 2 to 3 years
Look at Essendon* and Sydney in the last year or two
Get it right we will have really good team in a few years that will march to a top 4 position.
With Weitering McKay Cripps Walsh and a few others there we can be up there again
Give away picks and salary cap space for overrated players like we have stupidly done and you won’t go far
Proof this year more than any other
Don’t give up a first rounder for a guy who doesn’t play like a first rounder
And again
Clubs like us do not look closely enough at the WAFL SANFL
Jye Bolton would have walked into any AFL midfield
He is in his late 20s now probably missed his chance
Still dominating at Claremont mind you
Why? Clubs like us are simply dumb about this and focus on giving up quality picks for overrated players
when they can get decent ready made players with late and rookie picks