TalkingCarlton :: View topic - Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017

Mods can you please get Poster Walsh to change his name?

CFC8795 wrote:

Mods can you please get Poster Walsh to change his name?

I second that , can he change it to Murphy that would make more sense ...

Love Sayers, it’s Friday, MASSIVE!

Blue Vain wrote:

Walsh wrote:

Liddle had no football director to work with - his administrative acumen on the commercial side was good. But can't expect him to be a football director as well.

As for Cook he is 65 years old and of preservation age.

So you'll want Cook moved on if the alternative board is elected?

I'll take Cook on as a part time three day per week consultancy link between Football director and CEO but not CEO.

Cazzesman wrote:

Beijing Blue wrote:

Walsh wrote:

Hey! 65 is not old. Experienced is a more preferable term.

Was I dreamin' or did Mr Walsh spend many pages alerting us all to the fact that the multi billion dollar European Soccer clubs do it so much better than the rest. Now he tells us 65 is to old.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/footb ... unich.html

You need to check your stats book Walshy, I think your crayons have run and smudged the numbers.

Neil Balme is 69. Would you knock him back?

Regards Cazzesman

As a new employee to the club - absolutely would knock Balme back. Would I sack him if he is 65 or 69 years old - absolutely not.

People at the club won't be doing there job properly if they can't find appropriate long term solutions.

Off field stability has gone up the shit because someone thought it was wise to play the power tripper.

Cazzesman wrote:

Beijing Blue wrote:

Walsh wrote:

Hey! 65 is not old. Experienced is a more preferable term.

Walsh wrote:

Walshy!

Not good.

60's these days is what the 40's were 30 years ago.

I'm not even grey...yet...and I'm a similar genre as Cook.

I set the pace in my world ... ask London.

65 isn't old...Cook has kept his mind active and on top of his game.
He knows the role by heart.

If only we could get him.....fingers crossed.

Walsh wrote:

Cazzesman wrote:

Beijing Blue wrote:

Walsh wrote:

Hey! 65 is not old. Experienced is a more preferable term.

You are blaming the Board for on field instability the Review exposed, which was Liddle's responsibility to ensure?

Come on. There were issues with motivation, Defensive mindet, Game Plan before the review came to light...refer to TC discussions over the year, or two.

Buggered if I know how someone who claims to be “just another supporter with no connections at the club” knows so much about who did what right and wrong over so many years.

You’d have to have an inside connection (in which case you’re full of shit) or you’re pretending to know stuff you can’t possibly know (in which case you’re full of shit).

GWS wrote:

No, just a superior IQ than you.

bondiblue wrote:

Walsh wrote:

It's all abit pointless Bondi. We all know nothing will fit the narrative Walshy wants to push, which is Teague Good, Sayers Bad.

He will come up with some flippant reason as to why Cook is not up to it. Nothing of substance, just a throw away line that means Jack Shite.

I notice he hasn't responded to my media link that shows his beloved soccer Teams in Europe can't get enough of the old and wise.

Regards Cazzesman

Sayers is the man we have been waiting for. I’m convinced.

SurreyBlue wrote:

Sayers is the man we have been waiting for. I’m convinced.

I’m starting to think the same thing

Author:	azzablue [ Fri Sep 10, 2021 4:24 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017 – Sakced Sep 2021
CFC8795 wrote: Mods can you please get Poster Walsh to change his name? I second that , can he change it to Murphy that would make more sense ...

Author:	CFC8795 [ Fri Sep 10, 2021 4:28 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017 – Sakced Sep 2021
azzablue wrote: CFC8795 wrote: Mods can you please get Poster Walsh to change his name? I second that , can he change it to Murphy that would make more sense ... We have a Mover and a Seconder. All those in favour say "Aye" Carried unanimously!

Author:	bondiblue [ Fri Sep 10, 2021 4:57 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017 – Sakced Sep 2021
The Normal One wrote: Love Sayers, it’s Friday, MASSIVE! Massive Friday

Author:	Cazzesman [ Fri Sep 10, 2021 5:22 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017 – Sakced Sep 2021
Walsh wrote: Blue Vain wrote: Walsh wrote: Liddle had no football director to work with - his administrative acumen on the commercial side was good. But can't expect him to be a football director as well. As for Cook he is 65 years old and of preservation age. So you'll want Cook moved on if the alternative board is elected? I'll take Cook on as a part time three day per week consultancy link between Football director and CEO but not CEO. Why not CEO? In those immortal words from our resident right wing Ranga 'Please Explain!' Regards Cazzesman

Author:	Cazzesman [ Fri Sep 10, 2021 5:24 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017 – Sakced Sep 2021
Walsh wrote: Cazzesman wrote: Beijing Blue wrote: Walsh wrote: Liddle had no football director to work with - his administrative acumen on the commercial side was good. But can't expect him to be a football director as well. As for Cook he is 65 years old and of preservation age. Hey! 65 is not old. Experienced is a more preferable term. Was I dreamin' or did Mr Walsh spend many pages alerting us all to the fact that the multi billion dollar European Soccer clubs do it so much better than the rest. Now he tells us 65 is to old. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/footb ... unich.html You need to check your stats book Walshy, I think your crayons have run and smudged the numbers. Neil Balme is 69. Would you knock him back? Regards Cazzesman As a new employee to the club - absolutely would knock Balme back. Would I sack him if he is 65 or 69 years old - absolutely not. People at the club won't be doing there job properly if they can't find appropriate long term solutions. Off field stability has gone up the shit because someone thought it was wise to play the power tripper. Do you think the Off Field stability has been good before the start of August 2021? Regards Cazzesman

TalkingCarlton https://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/

Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017 – Sakced Sep 2021 https://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=36025	Page 39 of 41

Author:	bondiblue [ Fri Sep 10, 2021 5:27 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017 – Sakced Sep 2021
Walsh wrote: Liddle had no football director to work with - his administrative acumen on the commercial side was good. But can't expect him to be a football director as well. As for Cook he is 65 years old and of preservation age. Walshy! Not good. 60's these days is what the 40's were 30 years ago. I'm not even grey...yet...and I'm a similar genre as Cook. I set the pace in my world ... ask London. 65 isn't old...Cook has kept his mind active and on top of his game. He knows the role by heart. If only we could get him.....fingers crossed.

Author:	bondiblue [ Fri Sep 10, 2021 5:31 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017 – Sakced Sep 2021
Liddle openly admitted on the night of Teague's sacking and again in club email today, the failings have been under his watch. He reports to the Board, and manages and recruits the Football Dept and Admin roles. Nothing to do with the Board. Moving Liddle couldn't be a surprise to anyone who took an interest in some of his actions over the last 3 years. he was not CEO material, but a good marketer. We knew he was a good Marketer.

Author:	bondiblue [ Fri Sep 10, 2021 5:34 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017 – Sakced Sep 2021
Walsh wrote: Cazzesman wrote: Beijing Blue wrote: Walsh wrote: Liddle had no football director to work with - his administrative acumen on the commercial side was good. But can't expect him to be a football director as well. As for Cook he is 65 years old and of preservation age. Hey! 65 is not old. Experienced is a more preferable term. Was I dreamin' or did Mr Walsh spend many pages alerting us all to the fact that the multi billion dollar European Soccer clubs do it so much better than the rest. Now he tells us 65 is to old. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/footb ... unich.html You need to check your stats book Walshy, I think your crayons have run and smudged the numbers. Neil Balme is 69. Would you knock him back? Regards Cazzesman As a new employee to the club - absolutely would knock Balme back. Would I sack him if he is 65 or 69 years old - absolutely not. People at the club won't be doing there job properly if they can't find appropriate long term solutions. Off field stability has gone up the shit because someone thought it was wise to play the power tripper. You are blaming the Board for on field instability the Review exposed, which was Liddle's responsibility to ensure? Come on. There were issues with motivation, Defensive mindet, Game Plan before the review came to light...refer to TC discussions over the year, or two.

Author:	bondiblue [ Fri Sep 10, 2021 5:37 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017 – Sakced Sep 2021
Financial Stability. New Coach New CEO New Board Members New Assistants New ... Football Manager?? Another Preseason Injuries and Surgeries behind us Improved list in 2022 Rubbing hands...I've got something New to look forward to. Things can only get better.

Author:	Cazzesman [ Fri Sep 10, 2021 5:38 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017 – Sakced Sep 2021
bondiblue wrote: Walsh wrote: Liddle had no football director to work with - his administrative acumen on the commercial side was good. But can't expect him to be a football director as well. As for Cook he is 65 years old and of preservation age. Walshy! Not good. 60's these days is what the 40's were 30 years ago. I'm not even grey...yet...and I'm a similar genre as Cook. I set the pace in my world ... ask London. 65 isn't old...Cook has kept his mind active and on top of his game. He knows the role by heart. If only we could get him.....fingers crossed. It's all abit pointless Bondi. We all know nothing will fit the narrative Walshy wants to push, which is Teague Good, Sayers Bad. He will come up with some flippant reason as to why Cook is not up to it. Nothing of substance, just a throw away line that means Jack Shite. I notice he hasn't responded to my media link that shows his beloved soccer Teams in Europe can't get enough of the old and wise. Regards Cazzesman

Author:	SurreyBlue [ Fri Sep 10, 2021 6:11 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017 – Sakced Sep 2021
Sayers is the man we have been waiting for. I’m convinced.

Author:	Walsh [ Fri Sep 10, 2021 6:37 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017 – Sakced Sep 2021
bondiblue wrote: Walsh wrote: Cazzesman wrote: Beijing Blue wrote: Walsh wrote: Liddle had no football director to work with - his administrative acumen on the commercial side was good. But can't expect him to be a football director as well. As for Cook he is 65 years old and of preservation age. Hey! 65 is not old. Experienced is a more preferable term. Was I dreamin' or did Mr Walsh spend many pages alerting us all to the fact that the multi billion dollar European Soccer clubs do it so much better than the rest. Now he tells us 65 is to old. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/footb ... unich.html You need to check your stats book Walshy, I think your crayons have run and smudged the numbers. Neil Balme is 69. Would you knock him back? Regards Cazzesman As a new employee to the club - absolutely would knock Balme back. Would I sack him if he is 65 or 69 years old - absolutely not. People at the club won't be doing there job properly if they can't find appropriate long term solutions. Off field stability has gone up the shit because someone thought it was wise to play the power tripper. You are blaming the Board for on field instability the Review exposed, which was Liddle's responsibility to ensure? Come on. There were issues with motivation, Defensive mindet, Game Plan before the review came to light...refer to TC discussions over the year, or two. There is an issue with backing in your conviction and decisions until that conviction is exhausted. We have issues with the list, injury list, and midfield in particular, appropriate support and perhaps even football department structure and no football director. As said countless times - defensive mindset was always there but its hard to defend when you are not halving the contest as midfield is weakest in the comptition.

Author:	The Normal One [ Fri Sep 10, 2021 6:46 pm ]
Post subject:	Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017 – Sakced Sep 2021
Brilliant job commercially, but as the President said, it’s also the football department that was under his watch.

Author:	Walsh [ Fri Sep 10, 2021 6:47 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017 – Sakced Sep 2021
The football department had no leader nor guidance its funny that under Judd's watch is what fell apart the worst.

Page 39 of 41	All times are UTC + 10 hours
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/

Author:	GWS [ Fri Sep 10, 2021 6:51 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017 – Sakced Sep 2021
Buggered if I know how someone who claims to be “just another supporter with no connections at the club” knows so much about who did what right and wrong over so many years. You’d have to have an inside connection (in which case you’re full of shit) or you’re pretending to know stuff you can’t possibly know (in which case you’re full of shit).

Author:	Walsh [ Fri Sep 10, 2021 6:57 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017 – Sakced Sep 2021
GWS wrote: Buggered if I know how someone who claims to be “just another supporter with no connections at the club” knows so much about who did what right and wrong over so many years. You’d have to have an inside connection (in which case you’re full of shit) or you’re pretending to know stuff you can’t possibly know (in which case you’re full of shit). No, just a superior IQ than you.

Author:	GWS [ Fri Sep 10, 2021 7:01 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017 – Sakced Sep 2021
Walsh wrote: GWS wrote: Buggered if I know how someone who claims to be “just another supporter with no connections at the club” knows so much about who did what right and wrong over so many years. You’d have to have an inside connection (in which case you’re full of shit) or you’re pretending to know stuff you can’t possibly know (in which case you’re full of shit). No, just a superior IQ than you. Your ego is out of control. I was referring to Cazzesman.

Author:	keogh [ Fri Sep 10, 2021 7:07 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017 – Sakced Sep 2021
Cazzesman wrote: bondiblue wrote: Walsh wrote: Liddle had no football director to work with - his administrative acumen on the commercial side was good. But can't expect him to be a football director as well. As for Cook he is 65 years old and of preservation age. Walshy! Not good. 60's these days is what the 40's were 30 years ago. I'm not even grey...yet...and I'm a similar genre as Cook. I set the pace in my world ... ask London. 65 isn't old...Cook has kept his mind active and on top of his game. He knows the role by heart. If only we could get him.....fingers crossed. It's all abit pointless Bondi. We all know nothing will fit the narrative Walshy wants to push, which is Teague Good, Sayers Bad. He will come up with some flippant reason as to why Cook is not up to it. Nothing of substance, just a throw away line that means Jack Shite. I notice he hasn't responded to my media link that shows his beloved soccer Teams in Europe can't get enough of the old and wise. Regards Cazzesman What about your narrative Cazzeman It is what it is All a bit wishy washy to me If it was Sayers and Sayers only deciding the coach Lyon would be it That would have put the final nail in the coffin As BV said get the best coach The question I would be asking is how are you going to be innovative That question should be asked to every candidate Clearly Ross wasn’t prepared to change Success in the past is almost irrelevant Change is ever constant And how are we going to develop our midfield depth Because it ain’t there Sayers says we plan to make finals How can you do that with 3 or 4 decent mids And what about the captaincy It stands out like dogs balls to me that Weitering should be captain Walsh deputy Cripps is not a good captain Too much like one of the boys Docherty is still going through hell So obvious matE Geeeezzzz your hard work Cazzeman

Author:	azzablue [ Fri Sep 10, 2021 7:27 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017 – Sakced Sep 2021
SurreyBlue wrote: Sayers is the man we have been waiting for. I’m convinced. I’m starting to think the same thing

Author:	Scotty12000 [ Fri Sep 10, 2021 8:02 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Cain Liddle - Appointed Nov 2017 – Sakced Sep 2021
azzablue wrote: SurreyBlue wrote: Sayers is the man we have been waiting for. I’m convinced. I’m starting to think the same thing Same here. Move over Teague Train, all aboard the SS Sayers (Walshy kept caged in the cargo hold with the other pets)