He didn't stand and watch. You can see him waving at him to hurry up just before it happened. There were 4 or 5 players around him but you only hold one responsible.

Errors are recorded here:
http://www.pro-stats.com.au/psw/web/gam ... id=2006123

He made 4 errors out of 24 disposals according to independent experts. That's hardly an error riddled game. Is at least prepared to take a few risks but sometimes they don't come off. The more you get of the ball the more likely you are to make errors. He got more of it than Campo & had more effect on the game. Sure every one made errors. Where's your analysis of Kouta's error riddled game? Or anyone else. We know you can't stand him. Your constant bagging's getting a bit tiresome. Enough's enough.

As I said make of those rankings whatever you want.

He didn't stand and watch. You can see him waving at him to hurry up just before it happened. There were 4 or 5 players around him but you only hold one responsible.

Errors are recorded here:
http://www.pro-stats.com.au/psw/web/gam ... id=2006123

He made 4 errors out of 24 disposals according to independent experts. That's hardly an error riddled game. Is at least prepared to take a few risks but sometimes they don't come off. The more you get of the ball the more likely you are to make errors. He got more of it than Campo & had more effect on the game. Sure every one made errors. Where's your analysis of Kouta's error riddled game? Or anyone else. We know you can't stand him. Your constant bagging's getting a bit tiresome. Enough's enough.

As I said make of those rankings whatever you want.

Adam Bentick is very good at laying shepherds for his teammates and we need more players who are willing to do some of the unfashionable aspects of the game

Houlihan didnt attempt to block or shepherd the tackler...he waited for the handpass..he wanted the soft possie...not the 1% er....wont be a good footballer and we wont be a good team until we start doing those things...
I would have backed Kade Simpson for example to do more than just stand there and wait for the handpass....I would have dragged Houlihan for that error and explained what is required or any other player who didnt
do the right thing.....you want Thornton to back himself but he needs to know other players are backing him up as well.....Adam Bentick is very good at laying shepherds for his teammates and we need more players who are willing to do some of the unfashionable aspects of the game....

Was reading the Herald Sun and i was SHOCKED to see Kouta (whom i thought was one of our better players for the day) had the 4th lowest ranking points.

What shocked me even more was seeing players like McGrath/French higher than him???

What shocked me even more is that Kouta is listed as having 7 Clangers, whilst McGrath is listed as having none! Nuthing! Zip!

WTF?????

Just watched a replay of the game and i have no idea how the Herald Sun comes up with these F@%&#! scores. I really don't.

Clanger, in the Sun, is listed as:-


So does that mean the pathetic grubber of a kick from Mcgrath that couldn't even hit a running Kennedy who was just 30mtrs out from goal, WASN'T an error?

Or the crap handball to nobody late in the last quater that resulted in an Essendon* goal to Hille................THAT WASN'T AN ERROR?

French did F@%&#! all thourghout the whole day, was destroyed in the ruck, and he gets a better score than Chris Bryan????

French - 8 Pos, 2 marks, 11 hit-outs, 1 (so-called) clanger and 0 goals 0 behinds = 76 Ranking points?????????????????

Bryan - 12 Pos, 7 Marks, 14 Hiy-outs, 1 (so-called) clanger and 1 goal 1 behind = 64 Ranking points??????????????????

That's a laugh!

Stevens & Houlihans game was riddled with Errors yet they still make it in the best?
(Note:- i'll back away from Houla cause whilst he made a few errors that reulted in turn-overs etc, etc, he DID keep Campo to a low 17 disposals which is an achievement. And he did set up a goal for Fev and kicked one of his own!)

Walker was listed as having a 'Dirty Game' by both commentators on Fox Footy. But after watching it again, i'm thinking he had a pretty decent game.

Walker was responsible for 3 CRUCIAL Spoils in the last qtr alone, including one in the dying 20sec of the game that could have resulted in Essendon* gaining just that extra point needed to win the game!

Does everybody believe that Walker's game was that BAD? Or Kouta's?