17th Premiership wrote:
I’m not sure why so many people are bagging Crippa. He may not be winning the Brownlow this year but he is probably leading our B&F. He may not be up to his usual standard but he is still one of the best in the competition at what he does.
The onus is on the coaching group to use him in the best way. And he may be trying to do too much but he’s not Robinson Crusoe there and at least he is trying to do something!
Oh, and I think there is an independent nominations committee which is supposed to recommend new Board members to the Board but I don’t know who they are and don’t believe it is transparent. I am a member and have been for a long time. However, I don’t think only paid up members can express their opinions. Yes, you must be paid up to vote but only a very small percentage of members show up to vote. And I also don’t think that paying more money should entitle you to have veto rights as has often been the case - and the problem - at Carlton.
And, you can very seriously influence the direction of the club by withholding your membership and in many cases that may be the final straw for sacking a coach - if continuing with the coach means too many members dropping off.
Also, the players don’t pay membership fees and they have a very strong influence on club decisions by their actions on and off the field.
Most importantly, TC is NOT the Board. It is an open group for all of us to express our views. Am I wrong?
I'll have a go.
Cripps up until the end of the 3rd quarter last week had 0 clearances, then they gave him a free and he just bombed it into F50 for a quick rebound IIRC.
He finished with 14 disposals and 2, that's right, 2 clearances.
Cripps is our midfield clearance player, he has 1 gear, can't go forward and kick goals (3 goals 7 with a goal kicking accuracy of 21.4%), he can't ruck because he can't jump (1 HO), he only took 1 mark and he is 195cm and he is now getting tackled too easily.
So my question to you is where would you play him if you were coach?
I know where I would, in the 2s.
And I highly doubt he is leading our B&F, that is lunacy.