Blue Vain wrote:
bondiblue wrote:
CK95 wrote:
I wouldn't mind seeing Plowman given a chance on Toby
You're cruel
Plowman has a decent record against the best small/mid forwards. At times he has been taken to the cleaners but that's because they
are the best forwards and they can turn it on against anyone. Even SOS conceded some big bags.
I'd possibly favour Williams but if that doesn't work, Plowman is the next best option.
IF Plowman can play body on body when the ball is coming in, Toby wont outmark him.
I don't rate Plowman's ability against smaller players like you. You can count a handful of opponents he's beaten, but IMO he's lost more battles against smaller opponents than won, and it got to the point where he lost fans, including me. His game became stiff, dour, and clumsy.
I know what Plowman was like before he came to Carlton. SOS pigeon holed Plowman as a defender, and until his last game, all he became was a dour defender. Last game however, he took on the game. He had a bit of luck go his way with umpires (who usually wrongly crucify him).
My no. 1 opponent is Williams. Both about same height, but Williams will have to play close to him when ball is heading Greene's way. Next in line I thought I'd have Saad but Greeney may be a bit strong for Saady body on body, hence I would go next with Plowman too.