gerry atric wrote:
Doc Sherrin wrote:
Feels more like a club now than it has for a long, long time. Embrace change MS.
Yeah, I am not sure Doc, feels more like corporation than a club, a middling company with average decision makers desperate to cover over the cracks. I may be accused of staying in the past, but I loved the club from when I first followed my father's allegiance, and they have rewarded me greatly, I have been at the MCG for all 8 flags since 1968, but we are in the dying days of a great and unique competition. We are now aping Euro soccer where players run the game. Our strength was our clubs and now it is turning into a grubby business of buy and sell. Free Agency has handed the power to players and their slimy managers. The players should realise that they are extremely privileged and that privilege is based on a competition built around clubs for 150 years from the VFA to the VFL to the AFL. Any player who reckons thay are not doing well should talk to a cricketer how much is the 300th best Victorian cricketer getting paid? He'd be paying subs, the 300 best AFL player would be on about $300k.
Once it is controlled by player/managers the game loses what made it great and what made fans love and support it in such numbers. Why bother with drafting and development, just go down the bottom for a few years build up draft picks, swap them for established players, bring in 15 FAs over a few years and maybe you'll win a flag. The corporation will be successful, the brand will be noticed, the shareholders should be satisfied, but the supporters may have ceased to care. I used to love the team and the game. Now it doesn't hurt that much if we lose and will hurt less as players come and go like one hit wonders in the charts.
I am sure I will be told to get with the program or eff off, in which case I'll choose the latter.
I understand your viewpoint. There is a limit to this Free Agency period before it comes distasteful. I think the end result of free agency is that it will make the stronger clubs stronger. We already have a two tiered competition-expect it to get more two-tiered eg Sylvia to Fremantle.
The Paul Chapman delisting I find more distasteful than any free agency trade though. Treating a champion of the game like what Geelong has done is not what I want to see. Where is the respect for him from this club?
There are still good stories in the game...even if they all end up being about the champion team (which leaves Carlton eating its dust) Hawthorn.
This loyalty to Max Bailey from the Hawks was admirable.
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-10-05/b ... out-on-topThe fact of the matter is that we either embrace the Hawthorn/Sydney model of success (ie utilising trades/free agency) or we all end up secretely wishing we were Hawthorn/Sydney supporters. Carlton is a mediocre side. Anything to lift it beyond being mediocre I am in favour of.