Sorry Jim but that's incorrect IMO. JW has played well at times as a KPP but he has little consistency as one.
As a CHB, he was taken apart too often and made poor decisions with the ball. As a CHF, he hasn't shown the capacity to play the role well with any consistency. His best season was as a floating back man. Unfortunately that role has become redundant for players with average foot skills.
He's been at the club for about 12 years now yet players with half the AFL exposure are far more consistent and disciplined.

[
It's that mentality which was one of the main precursors to our spoon years.

My mentality is to keep the blue bloods at home for ever. By keeping the blues at our football club the young players will meet, learn and follow the rich history of our once reveared football club.
By the way our precursor to our spoon years was to trade veteran players from other clubs instead of blooding and teaching kids. (just my opinion)

Waite plus pick one for Goddard

I'll keep pick #1 thanks. How did we get that off GWS exactly?

Jarrads not going anywhere. A good preseason and a resolution to his injury probelms will see him become the most dominate CHF in the game next season.

We say this every year since 2009, and every year it doesn't eventuate.

Jarrads not going anywhere. A good preseason and a resolution to his injury probelms will see him become the most dominate CHF in the game next season.

dominates his position for ten minutes before threatening to have himself rubbed out and add to his enormous tally of free kicks against.

should have been trade bait to bring a kid like caddy to the club.

instead we throw good money at him.
underperforming and almost thirty

You criticise him for giving away stupid free kicks then in another thread you say bring back Fev

Most dominant CHF in the game
Ever heard of Cloke? Chokes under pressureBrown?Was once, now spends a lot of time injured, sound familar Buddy?yeah not bad Kennedy?which one, neither are as good as Waite Riewoldt? you are kidding right? Was O.K as a running wide reciever up on the deep flank, useless in big games
Let's be realistic here, there's a difference between optimism and blind foolishness.

I just hope he can get on the park and contribute in a consistent manner.

You criticise him for giving away stupid free kicks then in another thread you say bring back Fev

funny
fev has produced more than waite.
fev will still go down as a great of the club.
with all his flaws he dominated his position in our worst ever era.

waite was unable to show more than glimpses.

Stick to talking about yourself BM, at least you know your subject matter there.

There's only one Kennedy when we're talking CHF's and he is already twice the value of Waite. Cloke is deservedly AA and Riewoldt had a poor year like Waite. Prior to that, he was twice the player Waite has ever been. I'm happy for us to talk up our players but lets try to add a semblance of reality.
And yeah, Buddy is "not bad"