TalkingCarlton :: View topic - Highlight of the Ch9 Coverage.

Eddie's two faced.

While I don't expect him to be pro-Carlton every time he mentions us, he only gets excited during Carlton matches so it looks like he has nothing against us and is a fair commentator.

Interesting to see what he'd be like if it was a Collingwood vs. Carlton WC GF.

phoenix johnson wrote:

He can't win...

Brereton did not utter one sensible comment all night.

I've never heard anyone talk so much shit on TV.

I can't stand Eddie's voice when he gets excited. Just sounds like a flower.

I gotta say, Eddie's call was pretty good. After all the shit I've hung on him, he did really well. See what happens when he's not calling a Filth match?

the downsides were Gary Lyon, who is just a tool, and Dermie, aka Captain Obvious. My mate calls him a grinning Jack O'Lantern.

Kaptain Kouta wrote:

good call, actually Ed has in all honesty has not been to unkind to us, has said he hates us but respects what we are about, and he is one of the best footy commentators going around when he is not calling Collingwood games. Dermie has got to be the biggest halfwit in football. Will never forget this piece of wisdom when Scotland was lining up for goal late in the last qtr to put us 21 pts in front. "West Coast would probably rather Carlton kick a goal here than a point so at least the ball would be back in the centre" :roll:

Yeah right Dermie, Doesnt matter if they got the ball back to centre, they had no one to kick it to because they f***ed around with it too much. He should go and bury his head in the same sand that he wanted his Hawks to draw a line across in that debacle against Essendon*

Bluesboy70 wrote:

Kaptain Kouta wrote:

Surely not! I can't recall hearing Dermie say that

Ponkstar wrote:

Bluesboy70 wrote:

Kaptain Kouta wrote:

Surely not! I can't recall hearing Dermie say that

Didnt actually say it but implied buy saying "as strange as it sounds, at least the ball would be back in the centre"

Author:	SHHH! [ Sun Mar 13, 2005 2:35 pm ]
Post subject:	Highlight of the Ch9 Coverage.
Having seen it on Foxtel 7 times so far. Eddie's call during the last 10 mins of the final quarter would have to go down as history making. Not only did he announce that " THEY"RE BACK" but he sounded actually genuine in his enthusiasm. Now I know that this is hard to imagine and even harder to expect that it was genuine but boy does it sound like it.

Author:	windy [ Sun Mar 13, 2005 3:12 pm ]
Post subject:
The Ch 9 coverage was good, particularly the complete broadcast of the trophy/medal presentation, our lap of honour/celebration and the coverage in our rooms, complete with club song and interviews. This was priceless PR for the club, and our new sponsor, Dan Murphys would be stoked, especially when a magnum (champers) was brought out at the end. Anyone who reckons the Wizard Cup isn't worthwhile, has their head buried in the sand. And this doesn't even take into account the positive effects on the preparation of the team for the season, nor the extra cash in the bank. The only negative in the coverage was Dermie, who didn't have a positive thing to say about the Blues. Even Eddie seemed to resist the impulse to blurt out Carrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrlton1

Author:	BlueWorld [ Sun Mar 13, 2005 3:14 pm ]
Post subject:
The only people that don't think the WC is worthwhile are those that didn't make it. Like those St supporters. They weren't saying that 12 months ago.

Author:	phoenix johnson [ Sun Mar 13, 2005 3:14 pm ]
Post subject:
How good was it to see Denis strongly embrace Lance last night? Their relationship has certainly turned the corner.

Author:	Kaptain Kouta [ Sun Mar 13, 2005 3:16 pm ]
Post subject:
I gotta say, Eddie's call was pretty good. After all the shit I've hung on him, he did really well. See what happens when he's not calling a Filth match? the downsides were Gary Lyon, who is just a tool, and Dermie, aka Captain Obvious. My mate calls him a grinning Jack O'Lantern.

TalkingCarlton http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/

Highlight of the Ch9 Coverage. http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=619	Page 1 of 3

Author:	fevolaaaa [ Sun Mar 13, 2005 3:23 pm ]
Post subject:
Eddie hasn't been that excited since the 99 PF

Author:	magic [ Sun Mar 13, 2005 3:30 pm ]
Post subject:
As much as i hate him, I actually thought Eddie had a great call last night

Author:	fevolaaaa [ Sun Mar 13, 2005 3:38 pm ]
Post subject:
phoenix johnson wrote: Eddie's two faced. While I don't expect him to be pro-Carlton every time he mentions us, he only gets excited during Carlton matches so it looks like he has nothing against us and is a fair commentator. Interesting to see what he'd be like if it was a Collingwood vs. Carlton WC GF. He can't win...

Author:	George Harris [ Sun Mar 13, 2005 4:10 pm ]
Post subject:
Brereton did not utter one sensible comment all night. I've never heard anyone talk so much shit on TV.

Author:	NTBlue [ Sun Mar 13, 2005 4:22 pm ]
Post subject:
George Harris wrote: Brereton did not utter one sensible comment all night. I've never heard anyone talk so much shit on TV. Spot on George. He talked crap all night, but thats his usual form. One thing did surprise me was that he contradicted Eddie at one stage. Eddie had just finished saying that the Eagles were drooping in the heat and then Dermie piped up that the Eagles would handle the heat better than the Blues. I couldn't believe what I had heard as Dermie is usually so eager to agree with Eddie.

Author:	CK95 [ Sun Mar 13, 2005 7:09 pm ]
Post subject:
I can't stand Eddie's voice when he gets excited. Just sounds like a flower. When Prenda kicks the goal in the last qtr I want to be able to hear the roar...instead it's overshadowed by Eddie sounding like he's just had a movement after 9 days of constipation.

Author:	camel [ Sun Mar 13, 2005 7:16 pm ]
Post subject:
CK95 wrote: I can't stand Eddie's voice when he gets excited. Just sounds like a flower. Wow, I had Eddie pencilled down as more of a Roger David man myself.

Author:	Wangers [ Sun Mar 13, 2005 8:07 pm ]
Post subject:
Dermie & G.Lyon are HACKS when it comes to special comments. They've only got gigs at Nine cause they're pissing in Eddie's pocket. I cannot believe why Nine haven't seen the light and sent these two imbeciles packing. If any commentator couldn't say anything positive about Carlton last night, no matter where their allegiances lie, then they shouldn't be allowed on air ever again. Suck Shit Dermie & Lyon you HACKS.

Author:	Bluesboy70 [ Sun Mar 13, 2005 9:51 pm ]
Post subject:
Kaptain Kouta wrote: I gotta say, Eddie's call was pretty good. After all the shit I've hung on him, he did really well. See what happens when he's not calling a Filth match? the downsides were Gary Lyon, who is just a tool, and Dermie, aka Captain Obvious. My mate calls him a grinning Jack O'Lantern. good call, actually Ed has in all honesty has not been to unkind to us, has said he hates us but respects what we are about, and he is one of the best footy commentators going around when he is not calling Collingwood games. Dermie has got to be the biggest halfwit in football. Will never forget this piece of wisdom when Scotland was lining up for goal late in the last qtr to put us 21 pts in front. "West Coast would probably rather Carlton kick a goal here than a point so at least the ball would be back in the centre" Yeah right Dermie, Doesnt matter if they got the ball back to centre, they had no one to kick it to because they f**ed around with it too much. He should go and bury his head in the same sand that he wanted his Hawks to draw a line across in that debacle against Essendon

Author:	thehalford [ Mon Mar 14, 2005 7:37 am ]
Post subject:
Yeah, I was wondering what the hell he was tooling on about there. He's useless.

Page 1 of 3	All times are UTC + 10 hours
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/

Author:	Ponkstar [ Sun Mar 13, 2005 10:58 pm ]
Post subject:
Bluesboy70 wrote: Kaptain Kouta wrote: I gotta say, Eddie's call was pretty good. After all the shit I've hung on him, he did really well. See what happens when he's not calling a Filth match? the downsides were Gary Lyon, who is just a tool, and Dermie, aka Captain Obvious. My mate calls him a grinning Jack O'Lantern. good call, actually Ed has in all honesty has not been to unkind to us, has said he hates us but respects what we are about, and he is one of the best footy commentators going around when he is not calling Collingwood games. Dermie has got to be the biggest halfwit in football. Will never forget this piece of wisdom when Scotland was lining up for goal late in the last qtr to put us 21 pts in front. "West Coast would probably rather Carlton kick a goal here than a point so at least the ball would be back in the centre" Yeah right Dermie, Doesnt matter if they got the ball back to centre, they had no one to kick it to because they f**ed around with it too much. He should go and bury his head in the same sand that he wanted his Hawks to draw a line across in that debacle against Essendon Surely not! I can't recall hearing Dermie say that (maybe becasue I was floating in a daze) but that is one of the most freaking stupid things I have ever heard in my life. Yeah, lets hope they kick a goal so we can get the ball out of the centre and then kick a goal so the scores will be back to exactly what they freaking well are now. Great game-plan Derm. Bloody awful haircut too.

Author:	Bluesboy70 [ Sun Mar 13, 2005 11:15 pm ]
Post subject:
Ponkstar wrote: Bluesboy70 wrote: Kaptain Kouta wrote: I gotta say, Eddie's call was pretty good. After all the shit I've hung on him, he did really well. See what happens when he's not calling a Filth match? the downsides were Gary Lyon, who is just a tool, and Dermie, aka Captain Obvious. My mate calls him a grinning Jack O'Lantern. good call, actually Ed has in all honesty has not been to unkind to us, has said he hates us but respects what we are about, and he is one of the best footy commentators going around when he is not calling Collingwood games. Dermie has got to be the biggest halfwit in football. Will never forget this piece of wisdom when Scotland was lining up for goal late in the last qtr to put us 21 pts in front. "West Coast would probably rather Carlton kick a goal here than a point so at least the ball would be back in the centre" Yeah right Dermie, Doesnt matter if they got the ball back to centre, they had no one to kick it to because they f**ed around with it too much. He should go and bury his head in the same sand that he wanted his Hawks to draw a line across in that debacle against Essendon Surely not! I can't recall hearing Dermie say that Didnt actually say it but implied buy saying "as strange as it sounds, at least the ball would be back in the centre"

Author:	phoenix johnson [ Sun Mar 13, 2005 11:16 pm ]
Post subject:
Bluesboy70 wrote: Ponkstar wrote: Bluesboy70 wrote: Kaptain Kouta wrote: I gotta say, Eddie's call was pretty good. After all the shit I've hung on him, he did really well. See what happens when he's not calling a Filth match? the downsides were Gary Lyon, who is just a tool, and Dermie, aka Captain Obvious. My mate calls him a grinning Jack O'Lantern. good call, actually Ed has in all honesty has not been to unkind to us, has said he hates us but respects what we are about, and he is one of the best footy commentators going around when he is not calling Collingwood games. Dermie has got to be the biggest halfwit in football. Will never forget this piece of wisdom when Scotland was lining up for goal late in the last qtr to put us 21 pts in front. "West Coast would probably rather Carlton kick a goal here than a point so at least the ball would be back in the centre" Yeah right Dermie, Doesnt matter if they got the ball back to centre, they had no one to kick it to because they f**ed around with it too much. He should go and bury his head in the same sand that he wanted his Hawks to draw a line across in that debacle against Essendon Surely not! I can't recall hearing Dermie say that Didnt actually say it but implied buy saying "as strange as it sounds, at least the ball would be back in the centre" Well at least he can acknowledge he's a flower.