TalkingCarlton :: View topic - R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion)

Tim English has been ruled out with concussion, per coach Beveridge.

:D are they going at 100% with English and 0% without? Can't remember... but I watched a couple of their No English games and they were inept. If they don't have a couple of their key defenders back, H could have a huge game - as long as we don't do something stupid like put him back to full time FF duties

I'm a fan of Kemp but he needs to get his head straight. Last night's misses were so deflating to the team. He just undoes everyone's hard work with poor kicking skills.

B: Florent, L Young, Cowan
HB: Newman, Weitering, Cera
C: Wilson, Cripps, O Hollands
HF: McKay, McGovern, Carroll
F: Hayward, Derksen, Ainsworth
Foll: Pitto, Smith, Walsh
Int: Williams, Hewitt, Dean, Evans, Kemp

I'm dropping Saad and Haynes. Young has to come in to give Weitering a chop out. Young to take Naughton. Harry to play high up the ground. Weitering to play high up to distribute further up the ground.

I want Wilson using his pace through the middle and Carroll hitting targets lace out inside 50. I want someone to lock down/tag Bailey Dale. Maybe Cera if he swapped with Derksen. Just make Dales life a misery. He is their driving force.

The Doggies have been running on fumes, so they are truly getable.

Regards Cazzesman

I am sure we will win the first half.

I'm not a huge Lewis fan but I'm sick of seeing Weits sitting on the goal line and then trailing his opponent to the contest by 5 metres. Naughton will kill him for speed. Capt Obviously will say it is all about the delivery he gets from the Doggies midfield, and I get that.

I just want to see Weiters getting the ball on defensive 50 and then kicking it 50 to some running wingers. I want him to quarterback and direct; not be the dour defender he has had to become.

If Lewis takes Naughton, then Dean can take Will Lewis.

Big game for Pitto. He has to dictate in the centre square. If Bont and Richards burst away from stoppages it will be a tough night.

Never a better chance to get a W.

Regards Cazzesman

I am sure we will win the first half.

Effes wrote:

Tim English has been ruled out with concussion, per coach Beveridge.

Great news
Now all we need is for Bont to be rested ,Naughton to knock himself out going for a hanger , Ed Richard to pop his hamstring again and Dale to put his boots on the wrong feet and we could be in with a big chance

Sent from my SM-F956B using Tapatalk

Pitto shouldn’t be playing. We are desperate.
Reidy was crap today.

Author:	Effes [ Sat May 09, 2026 8:34 am ]
Post subject:	R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion)
Tim English has been ruled out with concussion, per coach Beveridge.

Author:	Sydney Blue [ Sat May 09, 2026 9:40 am ]
Post subject:	Re: R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion)
Effes wrote: Tim English has been ruled out with concussion, per coach Beveridge. Great news Now all we need is for Bont to be rested ,Naughton to knock himself out going for a hanger , Ed Richard to pop his hamstring again and Dale to put his boots on the wrong feet and we could be in with a big chance Sent from my SM-F956B using Tapatalk

Author:	GreatEx [ Sat May 09, 2026 10:32 am ]
Post subject:	Re: R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion)
are they going at 100% with English and 0% without? Can't remember... but I watched a couple of their No English games and they were inept. If they don't have a couple of their key defenders back, H could have a huge game - as long as we don't do something stupid like put him back to full time FF duties

Author:	Navy One [ Sat May 09, 2026 12:56 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion)
Effes wrote: Tim English has been ruled out with concussion, per coach Beveridge. Thanks to Matty K for getting the ball rolling for us ..... it's in our court now

Author:	Traveller86 [ Sat May 09, 2026 1:36 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion)
Watching the amazing VFL performance, who comes in? Is Ison ready? Personally I’d hold him back until maybe the Essendon* game right before the bye. Acres dominated and deserves a recall but for who? Flynn Young surely, surely comes in for Evans.

TalkingCarlton http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/

R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion) http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=38560	Page 1 of 3

Author:	keogh [ Sat May 09, 2026 1:43 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion)
I would bring in Derkson and drop Pittonet Have McKay rucking

Author:	GreatEx [ Sat May 09, 2026 2:05 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion)
Pitto must be suffering the effects of the injury, started season well (60% caveat) but been putrid since returning. If we're going one ruck plus H, Reidy has earned a chance today. Don't want H as first ruck, the benefits wear off if he hardly gets any time up forward. F Young wasn't great today. Evans has been disappointing with his set shots but his F50 entries earn him a reprieve. Acres was very good but I'd rather he be senior leadership in the 2s for this season, only promoted in case of injury crisis. I like him, but he doesn't give us what we need to develop our fast ball movement game. Chesser I'd like to see in the AFL side later in the year, but let him keep developing his midfield game in the 2s for the next month or two.

Author:	Cazzesman [ Sat May 09, 2026 3:49 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion)
I'm a fan of Kemp but he needs to get his head straight. Last night's misses were so deflating to the team. He just undoes everyone's hard work with poor kicking skills. B: Florent, L Young, Cowan HB: Newman, Weitering, Cera C: Wilson, Cripps, O Hollands HF: McKay, McGovern, Carroll F: Hayward, Derksen, Ainsworth Foll: Pitto, Smith, Walsh Int: Williams, Hewitt, Dean, Evans, Kemp I'm dropping Saad and Haynes. Young has to come in to give Weitering a chop out. Young to take Naughton. Harry to play high up the ground. Weitering to play high up to distribute further up the ground. I want Wilson using his pace through the middle and Carroll hitting targets lace out inside 50. I want someone to lock down/tag Bailey Dale. Maybe Cera if he swapped with Derksen. Just make Dales life a misery. He is their driving force. The Doggies have been running on fumes, so they are truly getable. Regards Cazzesman

Author:	bondiblue [ Sat May 09, 2026 4:59 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion)
GreatEx wrote: :D are they going at 100% with English and 0% without? Can't remember... but I watched a couple of their No English games and they were inept. If they don't have a couple of their key defenders back, H could have a huge game - as long as we don't do something stupid like put him back to full time FF duties Goes to show how important one great ruck is, let alone two rucks. One great ruck trumps 2 average rucks or an average ruck and an average forward ruck. I know a lot of people don’t value the ruck since Grigg won a flag at the Tigers but the trend now is two rucks if you’ve got two competitive rucks. At least one great ruck who can ruck 80% is Gold. Pitto since returning after only one week rest from a broken hand has been a bit of a liability in the middle. In every game this year the oppositions goal streak has been sourced from CB. It’s a killer. Pitto shouldn’t be playing. We are desperate. Reidy was crap today. Harry can’t give us an advantage. Lucky we are up against a novice next week. Pitto can take him for 60% and Harry should be too experienced for him.

Author:	keogh [ Sat May 09, 2026 6:34 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion)
Cazzesman wrote: I'm a fan of Kemp but he needs to get his head straight. Last night's misses were so deflating to the team. He just undoes everyone's hard work with poor kicking skills. B: Florent, L Young, Cowan HB: Newman, Weitering, Cera C: Wilson, Cripps, O Hollands HF: McKay, McGovern, Carroll F: Hayward, Derksen, Ainsworth Foll: Pitto, Smith, Walsh Int: Williams, Hewitt, Dean, Evans, Kemp I'm dropping Saad and Haynes. Young has to come in to give Weitering a chop out. Young to take Naughton. Harry to play high up the ground. Weitering to play high up to distribute further up the ground. I want Wilson using his pace through the middle and Carroll hitting targets lace out inside 50. I want someone to lock down/tag Bailey Dale. Maybe Cera if he swapped with Derksen. Just make Dales life a misery. He is their driving force. The Doggies have been running on fumes, so they are truly getable. Regards Cazzesman Agree

Author:	SurreyBlue [ Sun May 10, 2026 12:26 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion)
I’m not sure I agree that we need LYoung in this week. Doggies have a small KP forward line. I think Harry and Kemp can get on top of their KP (Buku ) as well. Having said that, I’m sure we’ll be bringing Lewis back in this week now.

Author:	Cazzesman [ Sun May 10, 2026 12:51 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion)
I'm not a huge Lewis fan but I'm sick of seeing Weits sitting on the goal line and then trailing his opponent to the contest by 5 metres. Naughton will kill him for speed. Capt Obviously will say it is all about the delivery he gets from the Doggies midfield, and I get that. I just want to see Weiters getting the ball on defensive 50 and then kicking it 50 to some running wingers. I want him to quarterback and direct; not be the dour defender he has had to become. If Lewis takes Naughton, then Dean can take Will Lewis. Big game for Pitto. He has to dictate in the centre square. If Bont and Richards burst away from stoppages it will be a tough night. Never a better chance to get a W. Regards Cazzesman

Author:	sinbagger [ Sun May 10, 2026 12:53 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion)
I am sure we will win the first half.

Author:	TAFKA BamBam7 [ Sun May 10, 2026 1:16 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion)
sinbagger wrote: I am sure we will win the first half. Honestly, I'd take that.

Author:	diesel95 [ Sun May 10, 2026 3:35 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion)
Derksen for Kemp?! A bit optimistic i know, but as @Cazzesman said, just so deflating when he undoes all the team momentum with missed ‘easy’ shots. I'm by no means a Kemp hater, and thought he's been the difference up forward for some games this year, giving Gov and H a break from double manning contests and kicking some very good goals. The commentators give him more of a wrap that anybody on this forum that's for sure! Wasn't he drafted as a big bodied mid? Does he have the tank to be onball when some of our young VFL forwards become seniors? He's almost got a Hugh McCluggage type physique, and reasonably mobile. he gets back into the defence at times probably when his opponent goes forward but ive never seen him play like a mid. Possibility? Saad didn't do much, and that Q4 HB over the shoulder was a shocker but who would you bring in for him? Wilson seemed out of his depth. Do they play sink or swim with him again or give him another 8 games in the twos to build his awareness? Cowan was only just ok. Florent, got a lot of it, coughed a lot of it. For a territory team ineffective kicking from the D50 is ok (Fly just said in his presser that Collingwood took AFL's most ineffective kicking team stat in their flag year) but we are trying to be much more than a dour territory team these days. Of the mid/small defenders, I thought Newman was the only one who was any good against Lions. I like the consistency he still brings each week. The rest of them were emblematic of CFC 2026 in their number of unforced errors, poor disposal, tackles that didn't sick, half-hearted running, lack of system in the fist half etc etc.

Page 1 of 3	All times are UTC + 10 hours
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/

Author:	GreatEx [ Sun May 10, 2026 1:48 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion)
Let's keep everyone guessing by making a hot start AND a storming finish but @#$%&! up the middle two quarters

Author:	Mickstar [ Sun May 10, 2026 2:02 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion)
Cazzesman wrote: I'm not a huge Lewis fan but I'm sick of seeing Weits sitting on the goal line and then trailing his opponent to the contest by 5 metres. Naughton will kill him for speed. Capt Obviously will say it is all about the delivery he gets from the Doggies midfield, and I get that. I just want to see Weiters getting the ball on defensive 50 and then kicking it 50 to some running wingers. I want him to quarterback and direct; not be the dour defender he has had to become. If Lewis takes Naughton, then Dean can take Will Lewis. Big game for Pitto. He has to dictate in the centre square. If Bont and Richards burst away from stoppages it will be a tough night. Never a better chance to get a W. Regards Cazzesman Yep , not only I would be bringing Lewis Young in for this game I would add Derkson into the team as well . Reckon Haynes is labouring myself . Give him a weeks rest .

Author:	sinbagger [ Sun May 10, 2026 2:23 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion)
sinbagger wrote: I am sure we will win the first half. Then likely the baby doggies (puppies) will storm home in the second half and we’ll either narrowly lose or narrowly win.

Author:	diesel95 [ Sun May 10, 2026 3:11 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion)
Sydney Blue wrote: Effes wrote: Tim English has been ruled out with concussion, per coach Beveridge. Great news Now all we need is for Bont to be rested ,Naughton to knock himself out going for a hanger , Ed Richard to pop his hamstring again and Dale to put his boots on the wrong feet and we could be in with a big chance Sent from my SM-F956B using Tapatalk I watch the replay of the Naughton grab over and over and I'm 100% sure he got tunnelled by the swans player running head on into him and his opponent. Blond hair, Warner or Henney? Naughton jumped almost straight ip vertically and didn't rotate even 1º in the marking contest but then got rotated 180º straight after ?Warner hit him below the waist. I was surprised nobody in the media or commenters calling the game bothered to mention it, people have been given frees against and possibly fines(?) for dangerous play for that kind of thing in the past. I guess nobody in AFL-land wants to Warner or Henney criticised or potentially rubbed out and lose their Brownlow cache. My mate who used to play says it's part of the no-dobbing culture of footy commentary. bloody fluke Naughton didn't cop a career ending injury the way he landed on his neck.

Author:	bluehammer [ Sun May 10, 2026 3:45 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R10: Carlton Vs WBD (Pre match discussion)
bondiblue wrote: Pitto shouldn’t be playing. We are desperate. Reidy was crap today. Reidy has been horrible at AFL level but he was anything but crap in the VFL. I had him in the best 3 in a 100+ pt win. Around the ground and at centre he was dominant. What didn't you like about his VfL game Bondi?