TalkingCarlton :: View topic - List Management 2025

What a surprise.... Geelong is actually the preferred option for Charlie Curnow!
I'm shocked...it's almost like the Sydney Swans/Gold Coast thing was devised by the manager to throw one off the scent. Who would have thunk it?

All the really good players (in Victoria) want to get to Geelong under the "equalisation" model we live under.

Here's a reminder. He's under contract and under NO conditions should he get to Geelong. Some club has to make a stand at some point to try and stop this misuse of the system.
If he is desperate to get out he goes to Richmond, North Melbourne, Essendon**, West Coast etc. Geelong play unders to get star players to their team. Jeremy Cameron for pick 13 and pick 15 effectively is a joke. Can anyone tell me what games by Ryan Angwin and Conor Stone for the GWS they can remember? How many times have Angwin and Stone been in the All-Australian squad? Oh that's right..none.

Trading is a complete joke. No more. Take a stand. Keep him at the club playing no games for the whole season...I don't care as long as he doesn't get to Geelong.

https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/teams/ ... 4634c37ebd

tap in 79 wrote:

What a surprise.... Geelong is actually the preferred option for Charlie Curnow!
I'm shocked...it's almost like the Sydney Swans/Gold Coast thing was devised by the manager to throw one off the scent. Who would have thunk it?

All the really good players (in Victoria) want to get to Geelong under the "equalisation" model we live under.

Here's a reminder. He's under contract and under NO conditions should he get to Geelong. Some club has to make a stand at some point to try and stop this misuse of the system.
If he is desperate to get out he goes to Richmond, North Melbourne, Essendon***, West Coast etc. Geelong play unders to get star players to their team. Jeremy Cameron for pick 13 and pick 15 effectively is a joke. Can anyone tell me what games by Ryan Angwin and Conor Stone for the GWS they can remember? How many times have Angwin and Stone been in the All-Australian squad? Oh that's right..none.

Trading is a complete joke. No more. Take a stand. Keep him at the club playing no games for the whole season...I don't care as long as he doesn't get to Geelong.

https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/teams/ ... 4634c37ebd

For Connor O’Sullivan, I’d drive him there myself.

tap in 79 wrote:

What a surprise.... Geelong is actually the preferred option for Charlie Curnow!
I'm shocked...it's almost like the Sydney Swans/Gold Coast thing was devised by the manager to throw one off the scent. Who would have thunk it?

All the really good players (in Victoria) want to get to Geelong under the "equalisation" model we live under.

Here's a reminder. He's under contract and under NO conditions should he get to Geelong. Some club has to make a stand at some point to try and stop this misuse of the system.
If he is desperate to get out he goes to Richmond, North Melbourne, Essendon***, West Coast etc. Geelong play unders to get star players to their team. Jeremy Cameron for pick 13 and pick 15 effectively is a joke. Can anyone tell me what games by Ryan Angwin and Conor Stone for the GWS they can remember? How many times have Angwin and Stone been in the All-Australian squad? Oh that's right..none.

Trading is a complete joke. No more. Take a stand. Keep him at the club playing no games for the whole season...I don't care as long as he doesn't get to Geelong.

https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/teams/ ... 4634c37ebd

For Connor O’Sullivan, I’d drive him there myself.

Forget Geelong they will offer nothing near mv
Swans won’t offer any guns so forget
GC are the one only one that might offer mv or more
OTHERWISE see you at pre season training Charlie and leave the bike home

Frank Carspew wrote:

what a surprise, of course Charlie wants to hang out with his chum Bailey.

hang tough Blues

london blue wrote:

Frank Carspew wrote:

what a surprise, of course Charlie wants to hang out with his chum Bailey.

hang tough Blues

He’s a big-time entrepreneur now.

Alcopops & mud baths are the future.

Crusader can you explain the reason and logic behind why the TDK pick would be on the market when we presumably need that pick and JSOS Pick for Dean and ISON

Are we trying to get another player in addition to Dean or ISON in the draft or is it to use on one of the players we are trying to get in

I get it is difficult to tell exactly what picks we need as Dean bid might need to be matched if someone goes early on him and he could go anywhere between about pick 5-15 and ISON could go pick 30 or so

Effes wrote:

May is finished.

Reminds me of when we recruited Mick Martyn

Humpers wrote:

Effes wrote:

May is finished.

Reminds me of when we recruited Mick Martyn

I reckon May would be terrible for on AND off field culture.

Humpers wrote:

Effes wrote:

May is finished.

Reminds me of when we recruited Mick Martyn

I reckon May would be terrible for on AND off field culture.

Author:	Crusader [ Wed Sep 17, 2025 4:45 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: List Management 2025
tap in 79 wrote: What a surprise.... Geelong is actually the preferred option for Charlie Curnow! I'm shocked...it's almost like the Sydney Swans/Gold Coast thing was devised by the manager to throw one off the scent. Who would have thunk it? All the really good players (in Victoria) want to get to Geelong under the "equalisation" model we live under. Here's a reminder. He's under contract and under NO conditions should he get to Geelong. Some club has to make a stand at some point to try and stop this misuse of the system. If he is desperate to get out he goes to Richmond, North Melbourne, Essendon**, West Coast etc. Geelong play unders to get star players to their team. Jeremy Cameron for pick 13 and pick 15 effectively is a joke. Can anyone tell me what games by Ryan Angwin and Conor Stone for the GWS they can remember? How many times have Angwin and Stone been in the All-Australian squad? Oh that's right..none. Trading is a complete joke. No more. Take a stand. Keep him at the club playing no games for the whole season...I don't care as long as he doesn't get to Geelong. https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/teams/ ... 4634c37ebd For Connor O’Sullivan, I’d drive him there myself.

Author:	Mickstar [ Wed Sep 17, 2025 4:55 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: List Management 2025
Crusader wrote: tap in 79 wrote: What a surprise.... Geelong is actually the preferred option for Charlie Curnow! I'm shocked...it's almost like the Sydney Swans/Gold Coast thing was devised by the manager to throw one off the scent. Who would have thunk it? All the really good players (in Victoria) want to get to Geelong under the "equalisation" model we live under. Here's a reminder. He's under contract and under NO conditions should he get to Geelong. Some club has to make a stand at some point to try and stop this misuse of the system. If he is desperate to get out he goes to Richmond, North Melbourne, Essendon***, West Coast etc. Geelong play unders to get star players to their team. Jeremy Cameron for pick 13 and pick 15 effectively is a joke. Can anyone tell me what games by Ryan Angwin and Conor Stone for the GWS they can remember? How many times have Angwin and Stone been in the All-Australian squad? Oh that's right..none. Trading is a complete joke. No more. Take a stand. Keep him at the club playing no games for the whole season...I don't care as long as he doesn't get to Geelong. https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/teams/ ... 4634c37ebd For Connor O’Sullivan, I’d drive him there myself. And I'll give you petrol money .

Author:	tap in 79 [ Wed Sep 17, 2025 5:01 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: List Management 2025
Crusader wrote: tap in 79 wrote: What a surprise.... Geelong is actually the preferred option for Charlie Curnow! I'm shocked...it's almost like the Sydney Swans/Gold Coast thing was devised by the manager to throw one off the scent. Who would have thunk it? All the really good players (in Victoria) want to get to Geelong under the "equalisation" model we live under. Here's a reminder. He's under contract and under NO conditions should he get to Geelong. Some club has to make a stand at some point to try and stop this misuse of the system. If he is desperate to get out he goes to Richmond, North Melbourne, Essendon***, West Coast etc. Geelong play unders to get star players to their team. Jeremy Cameron for pick 13 and pick 15 effectively is a joke. Can anyone tell me what games by Ryan Angwin and Conor Stone for the GWS they can remember? How many times have Angwin and Stone been in the All-Australian squad? Oh that's right..none. Trading is a complete joke. No more. Take a stand. Keep him at the club playing no games for the whole season...I don't care as long as he doesn't get to Geelong. https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/teams/ ... 4634c37ebd For Connor O’Sullivan, I’d drive him there myself. He's played 3 games...and might be good sometime down the track. We NEED two proven key forwards. Curnow is a proven good key forward. Sure he had injuries this year but in 2023/24 he had some great games - 2023 Kicked 6 vs Collingwood (The so-called best defence in the league) and 5 against Geelong in 2024. Under NO circumstances should he get to Geelong. It is an opinion game though...half glass full/half glass empty... Some say...yeah, let him get to Geelong and ensure they play in their 20th finals series in a row, others will say "No, hold onto him."

Author:	Frank Carspew [ Wed Sep 17, 2025 5:02 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: List Management 2025
Forget Geelong they will offer nothing near mv Swans won’t offer any guns so forget GC are the one only one that might offer mv or more OTHERWISE see you at pre season training Charlie and leave the bike home

Author:	london blue [ Wed Sep 17, 2025 5:09 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: List Management 2025
Frank Carspew wrote: Forget Geelong they will offer nothing near mv Swans won’t offer any guns so forget GC are the one only one that might offer mv or more OTHERWISE see you at pre season training Charlie and leave the bike home what a surprise, of course Charlie wants to hang out with his chum Bailey. hang tough Blues

TalkingCarlton http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/

List Management 2025 http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=38212	Page 119 of 153

Author:	Crusader [ Wed Sep 17, 2025 5:16 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: List Management 2025
The bloody bike Did he ride it home?

Author:	Crusader [ Wed Sep 17, 2025 5:18 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: List Management 2025
london blue wrote: Frank Carspew wrote: Forget Geelong they will offer nothing near mv Swans won’t offer any guns so forget GC are the one only one that might offer mv or more OTHERWISE see you at pre season training Charlie and leave the bike home what a surprise, of course Charlie wants to hang out with his chum Bailey. hang tough Blues He’s a big-time entrepreneur now. Alcopops & mud baths are the future.

Author:	Crusader [ Wed Sep 17, 2025 5:31 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: List Management 2025
The compensation pick for De Koning is on the market, according to Twomey. No surprises there. Probably slides all the way back to 13, unless we deal it to Gold Coast or Brisbane. Those two clubs are the only ones getting full points value.

Author:	Frank Carspew [ Wed Sep 17, 2025 7:28 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: List Management 2025
Crusader can you explain the reason and logic behind why the TDK pick would be on the market when we presumably need that pick and JSOS Pick for Dean and ISON Are we trying to get another player in addition to Dean or ISON in the draft or is it to use on one of the players we are trying to get in I get it is difficult to tell exactly what picks we need as Dean bid might need to be matched if someone goes early on him and he could go anywhere between about pick 5-15 and ISON could go pick 30 or so

Author:	london blue [ Wed Sep 17, 2025 8:11 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: List Management 2025
Crusader wrote: london blue wrote: Frank Carspew wrote: Forget Geelong they will offer nothing near mv Swans won’t offer any guns so forget GC are the one only one that might offer mv or more OTHERWISE see you at pre season training Charlie and leave the bike home what a surprise, of course Charlie wants to hang out with his chum Bailey. hang tough Blues He’s a big-time entrepreneur now. Alcopops & mud baths are the future. Ed and his old man need to have a word in his ear….they are good sensible people. Ultimately, so is Charlie. However, he’s getting ahead of himself.

Author:	Sidefx [ Wed Sep 17, 2025 8:12 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: List Management 2025
I'd assume it would be one of the following: 1. Trade back down the order for a player and a pick. i.e. Flanders and a 2nd rounder 2. Trade back down the order for picks, with overs going our way like we did last year for Smith. 2. Trade up the order with a Curnow or someone else for a gun player and/or picks. i.e. pick 1

Author:	Sidefx [ Wed Sep 17, 2025 8:19 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: List Management 2025
tap in 79 wrote: What a surprise.... Geelong is actually the preferred option for Charlie Curnow! I'm shocked...it's almost like the Sydney Swans/Gold Coast thing was devised by the manager to throw one off the scent. Who would have thunk it? All the really good players (in Victoria) want to get to Geelong under the "equalisation" model we live under. Here's a reminder. He's under contract and under NO conditions should he get to Geelong. Some club has to make a stand at some point to try and stop this misuse of the system. If he is desperate to get out he goes to Richmond, North Melbourne, Essendon**, West Coast etc. Geelong play unders to get star players to their team. Jeremy Cameron for pick 13 and pick 15 effectively is a joke. Can anyone tell me what games by Ryan Angwin and Conor Stone for the GWS they can remember? How many times have Angwin and Stone been in the All-Australian squad? Oh that's right..none. Trading is a complete joke. No more. Take a stand. Keep him at the club playing no games for the whole season...I don't care as long as he doesn't get to Geelong. https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/teams/ ... 4634c37ebd Busy week at Geelong: Charlie Curnow James Worpel Rowan Marshall And it is still September.

Author:	Crusader [ Wed Sep 17, 2025 9:39 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: List Management 2025
Frank Carspew wrote: Crusader can you explain the reason and logic behind why the TDK pick would be on the market when we presumably need that pick and JSOS Pick for Dean and ISON Are we trying to get another player in addition to Dean or ISON in the draft or is it to use on one of the players we are trying to get in I get it is difficult to tell exactly what picks we need as Dean bid might need to be matched if someone goes early on him and he could go anywhere between about pick 5-15 and ISON could go pick 30 or so Most likely they’re hoping to cash it in for more points, with a bonus pick in the top 30 before matching a bid for Ison. Shenanigans & team needs aside, I’ve got Dean rated in the late teens. It’s the lack of similar types that is driving his value up. Not that he isn’t a genuine top 20 pick, but there’s a bit of a Carlton tax to it. Xavier Taylor is the best pure defender in the draft. At 191cm he’s a half back, but will hold his own if dragged deep. Harry is the best of the full backs, but needs to be at 193cm. Just my opinion, but the mids are well underrated on the early rankings.

Author:	Humpers [ Thu Sep 18, 2025 9:14 am ]
Post subject:	Re: List Management 2025
Gold Coast won't be willing to trade any highly rated academy players or draft picks from this year as they are needed to obtain their 3 academy draft prospects. So I expect they might offer something like a future first + Ballard + Flanders for Charlie. Swans might be willing to offer their 2025 and 2026 1st round draft picks plus steak knives. Forget Geelong as they wouldn't get close to satisfying us in a trade.

Page 119 of 153	All times are UTC + 10 hours
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/

Author:	Sidefx [ Thu Sep 18, 2025 10:48 am ]
Post subject:	Re: List Management 2025
Shore up the backline for 1 year while HOF is out and Dean settles in? https://x.com/FootyonNine/status/1968468606921945449

Author:	Effes [ Thu Sep 18, 2025 11:13 am ]
Post subject:	Re: List Management 2025
May is finished. @#$%&! Geelong. If Curnow goes to GC, the deal has to involve Walter.

Author:	Humpers [ Thu Sep 18, 2025 11:14 am ]
Post subject:	Re: List Management 2025
Effes wrote: May is finished. Reminds me of when we recruited Mick Martyn

Author:	Effes [ Thu Sep 18, 2025 11:53 am ]
Post subject:	Re: List Management 2025
Humpers wrote: Effes wrote: May is finished. Reminds me of when we recruited Mick Martyn I reckon May would be terrible for on AND off field culture.

Author:	GMCbris [ Thu Sep 18, 2025 11:59 am ]
Post subject:	Re: List Management 2025
Effes wrote: Humpers wrote: Effes wrote: May is finished. Reminds me of when we recruited Mick Martyn I reckon May would be terrible for on AND off field culture. 100% agree with this

Author:	Crusader [ Thu Sep 18, 2025 12:14 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: List Management 2025
Effes wrote: Humpers wrote: Effes wrote: May is finished. Reminds me of when we recruited Mick Martyn I reckon May would be terrible for on AND off field culture. Yeah, but who here can say that they don’t want to punch Jake Melksham in the face?