diesel95 wrote:
keogh wrote:
I’ve been saying for 20 years on this website
The most important person at an AFL club is your List Manager
[…]
Our List Management strategy compared to the more successful clubs is shit. Pure and Simple.
[…]
We still recruit Haynes (But he costs nothing) He is past it. His year in 2024 proves it. Cooper Whyte would be a better option
But not at Carlton
[…]
Picks outside the top 30. Rookie picks.
[…]
That’s why they have been up there for so long
Same with Geelong and Sydney
When we recruit a 32 year old to the list you ask why
Haynes is obviously back up for a defender like Weiters if he goes down
[…]
You need 2 big key defenders
Adams retires because of concussion issues. Payne who was recruited as a kid with pick 54 steps up to support Andrews. That’s a classic example of good list management
Who is our support in the big bodied defensive department for Weiters
but how do you really feel, Keogh? a bit harsh i reckon.
i hope Hayes becomes more than a reserves player to fill in if Weiters is injured. he didn’t crack the AFL at GWS bc they didn’t want to mess with the formula that was working while he was out with guts issues for a year or so. doesn’t mean he is past it. Jones wasn’t past it when he returned to the Bulldogs at a similar age. I hope he pushes Young or Gov out of the first pick back six.
you praise Geelong’s recruiting, they snapped Jack Martin up same way we grabbed Haynes. Potentially a game winner if his durability issues were Russell “break-a-few-on-the-training-track” related. or potentially nothing much comes of it. footy ¯\_(ツ)_/¯.
as for recruiting a genuine tall KPD to compliment Weiters not just play when he can’t, i’m hoping pick #38 does just that for us. quite a few will be available thereabouts, maybe we can trade up to #32 or something.
trades we got right:
Newman, deserving second in the Nichols Medal 2024 just gets keeps getting better as his body drops from its peak.
Cerra, fair enough if jury remains undecided but has the development potential to become the class ball user in our midfield.
Hewitt, defied the doubters this season to take it to the next level, more versatile and more dependable outside of a lockdown role.
Saad, more upside than downside.
Fogarty, ditto.
Elijah Hollands, still improving, already good, doesn’t fu much which is something we can’t say for some.
probably others i’m forgetting.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
I meant Nathan Cooper not Cooper Whyte
Newman has been a great pick up for a fourth rounder
Hewett has been good as a free agent
Elijah Hollands an excellent selection for I think was basically a late second rounder
Saad has been very good but cost us basically a first rounder and I will argue to the cows come home he should be given time in the middle or at the very least a role further up the ground given we need leg speed and quick ball movement in this area
He is one of the few on our list that can do that
Fogarty in my opinion is overrated by many on this site
Is a goer but a limited player
Cerra cost us a first and third rounder
He was excellent last year injuries ducked him
this year. I rate him but he should deliver given what we gave up for him
I reckon Carlton and other clubs do not select enough blokes from the WAFL SANFL VFL Etc
I have been saying it for years on this site and will continue to do so
I would have picked Nathan Cooper over Haynes every day of the week
But Haynes is a proven AFL player
Cooper isnt
That’s the mentality of so many list management teams
Geelong is a bit of an outliner
Look at Humpries and Mannagh this year
Cooper is the sort of player we need a big bodied key defender who can support Weiters
Haynes is more of an interceptor
Cooper is 27 Haynes is 32
No brainer
I would have looked at Jacob Blight in last years mid season draft
Classic example of a late bloomer from Peel Thunder who is at the Tigers
If Weiters goes down we are captain cactus
I hope Cooper gets picked up by someone
B