Sidefx wrote:
bondiblue wrote:
Sidefx wrote:
Sydney Blue wrote:
After watching replay again there were a few that had howlers of games
Probably the worst game I have seen from TDK
Not sure if it was Cincotta / Fisher /Kemp marking Swallow but they need to take a good look at themselves
We allowed Flanders off the hook
Thought their midfield were far better
Harry was disappointing
Cunners struggled
Cripps way down
Thought Doc was a bit off as well
thank God for Charlie Weiters and Newman
Motlop stepped up once again after being quiet last week
Adding to that.
Hollands and Cottrell to a degree were owned again on the wing for the second week running, poor output from both.
Ed was a bust as sub.
Cincotta got exposed a bit.
I thought Dow had a really good game and it was great to watch him gain some form leading up to the finals.
Cottrell was huge for us.
I think 'huge' is a bit of an over exaggeration, Charlie was huge.
He kicked a good goal and done a couple of good defensive things but 11 disposals, 0 goal assists, 2 tackles, 2 marks and only 169m gained for 93% game time is not 'huge' IMO.
Each to their own I guess.
Charlie is GOD
Compared to your description of his game as "owned", "huge" is apt. You are way off the mark this week
A couple good defensive things? Surprised you even noticed him TBH.
Do you just look at the numbers/stats after the game and make your call based on that?
Its a team game. Players play roles. Its not the numbers that count for everything, and sometimes for nothing. What about the 16.5 kms he ran: match high.
Cincotta had Rosa
Newman had Swallow
Saad had Sexton
Fisher was the loose man filling holes to disable players like Swallow running hard towards goals
Weiters had Csboult
Kemp had Lucoscious
Marchbank had Chol
Hard to know who was minding who in a team defense system, but most of the time it was the above.
I think your man is Newman. What have you got to say to him?
I thought Cincotta sat on his man and won the battle after Rosas first goal of the match.
Yeah, each to their own.