keogh wrote:
Sidefx wrote:
keogh wrote:
If you look at the first 5 games we have been ordinary
Richmond have been crap all year
Geelong were still in party mode when we played them GWS are crap in arguably the worst game of the season so far. North are coming from a long way back and had no key defenders and we won by 4 goals
You can only hide the fact that the list has still enormous deficiencies
The loss of Docherty and Mc Govern last week was crucial
Both are good ball users from defense
Not quick but with the ball in their hands the pill can move forward quickly and effectively from the back
Saad provides the run
But even with these 3 guys in the team the speed in which the ball comes out from defence isn’t quick enough
Weitering Young Plowman Newman aren’t quick and don’t run and carry enough
The better teams have most defenders carrying the pill
Consequently we are easily played against
With 2 out we are in serious trouble
Why not try Dow at half back
Give him license to run
He wouldn’t be the first player to have his career saved by moving to the backline
Look at McGovern
This is why you need to watch the VFL.
Dow lacks a defensive side and defensive run, there is no way he can be a defender.
Saad doesn’t defend either
Ask Ben Keays
But you need players who run and gun out of defence
Good to see Cincotta get a run
I agree, except that is also not how Dow plays.
He's an extractor that follows the ball.
He is still working on his defensive side (I say this as it has gotten marginally better) and his attacking side is also a work in progress.
I want him to succeed but he needs to show more of a work rate to get into the team.
He is better than last year.
Cincotta is a good replacement for Saad, not as good by foot though.