17th Premiership wrote:
Paddycripps wrote:
So are these guys actually fit for selection?
Motlop - see previous Elvis sighting
C.Durdin - some saying he is cherry ripe, I will believe it when I see it
Marchbank - who the @#$%&! knows !!
Kemp - last seen hitch hiking along the Taiwanese coast
Newman - missed the last game, presumably due to training loads ? Or another one of these mysterious Carlton ailments
Martin - should be available for selection bec played VFL
McGovern - should be available for selection bec played VFL ... club saying they have a decision to make but I'd be surprised if he doesn't play (let's face it, the fact they are umming and erring is bec they don't trust his body!)
Cuningham - some posters are saying he trained the other day, but I suspect he was in the rehab group with Motlop and Amy Winehouse
Of those, I think Martin and McGov will play, as you’ve suggested. I reckon they’ve been managed to get to the start line ready but not overly risked.
I wouldn’t say Durdin looked ‘Cherry ripe’ b/c you couldn’t really say that from the type of training they were doing. But he seemed to be running freely. Cunningham was running around and didn’t look particularly troubled but then his risk is all about contact so, again, couldn’t tell. I imagine he will need to do a bit of strengthening work on his shoulder before we put him on the park with so much at stake club and for his career.
Who knows re Marchbank but my feel is that he comes back via the VFL.
And, as I posted in the game thread, I wouldn’t risk Motlop if there’s any doubt about his calf b/c (a) calves can be tricky and appear ok when fragile, and (b) the difference between Martin/Motlop/Owies is not that different at this stage to Martin/Owies/Durdin (or even Honey) as to warrant the risk. But if he’s absolutely fine, then fine
.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Yep good summary
Here's what I saw, player by player
Motlop - Did handballs with the rehab group, then moved to the Gardiner Stand wing for some one on one
C.Durdin - Trained well, ran at pace
Marchbank - Rehab group just at the start then went in
Kemp - Trained well with the main group, not sure if he was there the whole session
Newman - Trained fully
Martin - For the most part did set shots with Harry
McGovern - Rehab group just at the start then went in
Cunningham - Trained well, non contact drills
They have their main session tomorrow